The Carney government is proposing a regulatory rollback that goes farther than the most deregulatory moments of the Stephen Harper era, with proposals that would make it impossible to assess the health and environmental impacts of pipelines and other major resource projects, critics say.
The experts were reacting to the federal government’s sweeping overhaul of its project assessment processes, released Friday.
“It’s shocking,” said Anna Johnston, a staff lawyer at West Coast Environmental Law, who was extensively involved with development of the Trudeau government’s Impact Assessment Act. “This would represent by far the worst evisceration of environmental law in Canadian history, far worse than what happened under Prime Minister Harper’s government in 2012,” she told the Toronto Star.
“This goes beyond what Harper proposed when he was in power, yes, that’s true,” agreed MP and former environment and climate minister Steven Guilbeault (L, Laurier—Sainte-Marie).
If the proposed changes become law, “we will have no way of evaluating or understanding what are the human health and environment impacts of projects we are approving,” Guilbeault added. “The main criterion to evaluate projects moving forward, if this is adopted, is going to be economic development, and nothing else will matter.”
With exemptions to what the federal discussion paper calls the “jeopardy test”, the new rules would “grant any company or project the government chooses a blank cheque to just drive entire species to extinction or extirpation,” Phil Pothen, a land use, planning, environmental, and administrative lawyer at Environmental Defence Canada, told the Star.
Friday’s announcement launched a 30-day consultation period that closes June 6.
One Year to Consult
The discussion paper frames the changes as part of the government’s effort to diversify trade and compete globally. Under the current process, “building major projects like mines, ports, airports, pipelines, nuclear facilities, and transportation infrastructure is often slow, expensive, and confusing,” it states, with federal reviews sometimes running more than five years. In its Speech from the Throne last year, the Carney government pledged a two-year review window, and iPolitics says it is still in talks with Indigenous groups about how that would affect them.
Friday’s release proposes one year for project proponents to finalize their plans, then one year for federal review.
“While deadlines will not change Canada’s duty to consult Indigenous communities or fulfill obligations under modern treaties, we are creating a process that will lead to earlier and more coordinated consultation, and accordingly better and more efficient outcomes for Indigenous Peoples and proponents alike,” the paper states.
The new rules would shift review of pipeline projects from the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada to the Calgary-based Canada Energy Regulator (CER), while nuclear and uranium projects would become the responsibility of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC). Ottawa also wants to reverse the order of pipeline approvals, the Globe and Mail says, allowing the federal Cabinet to authorize projects before impact assessments and approvals are complete.
“To reduce risks and costs for investors, this decision would be made at the beginning of the decision process, before the CER completes its review of conditions and routing details,” the discussion paper states.
That proposal comes just two months before Alberta is expected to submit a pipeline proposal to the federal Major Projects Office, the Globe notes.
“This sends a message to investors and, frankly, to Canadian businesses that worry about our competitiveness,” said Intergovernmental Affairs Minister Dominic LeBlanc. “The government is going to ensure that we do all of these regulatory processes in a much more efficient and coherent way.”
Ottawa is proposing a new “Crown consultation hub” to address Indigenous communities’ “consultation fatigue” around major projects, and is calling for a concurrent process for assessment and permitting, “meaning the assessment process and the permitting process would happen at the same time,” iPolitics says. And the discussion paper proposes creation of new economic zones where Cabinet would have the authority to “pre-approve” development of transportation corridors, telecommunication networks, energy production and transmission, and industrial development.
Proceed With Caution
Those plans carry dire consequences, Environmental Defence Executive Director Tim Gray said in a release.
“Prime Minister Carney is putting Canada’s environment, waters, and rarest and most vulnerable species at risk if he proceeds with this proposal to bulldoze through projects without proper process,” Gray warned. “This proposal suggests, without evidence for need, that Canada should sacrifice the rule of law and our most sensitive species and ecosystems in order to build pipelines and other projects. If approved, this proposal will take Canada back to a more dangerous, toxic, and destructive time and leave Canadians facing impacts that could last for generations.”
The regulatory rollback also takes place after a period in which project review and approval processes were already “aggressively streamlined”, first by Stephen Harper’s Conservative government and then by Justin Trudeau’s Liberals, wrote Mark Winfield, a professor and co-chair of York University’s Sustainable Energy Initiative, in a post for The Conversation last June.
“It’s important to determine why projects are delayed in the first place,” Winfield explained. “Most move through assessment processes with little delay or controversy. Problems emerge when proposals are poorly designed, face serious technical or economic doubts, raise major environmental, climate, or safety concerns, and spark significant social, political, or legal conflicts over their costs, benefits, and impacts.”
He added that efforts to short-circuit regulatory processes can easily backfire. “If these processes are streamlined too much, the conclusions of these assessments may seem illegitimate. There could be a trade-off between clear, certain outcomes and ensuring the approval process is fair and trustworthy.”
That was what happened when the Harper government’s rollbacks “only escalated the spiralling political and legal conflicts” around a handful of very large pipeline proposals, resulting in a “tortuous process” by the time the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion was approved.
While there were other factors at play, the fossil industry routinely blames regulatory processes for Trans Mountain’s final price tag of $34 billion.
Winfield cited Ontario’s Green Energy Act, as well as the Muskrat Falls hydropower project in Labrador and the Site C dam in British Columbia, as instances where faster processes increased risks and costs that were ultimately borne by taxpayers, while undermining public confidence.
No Public Money for Pipelines
Even before Friday’s announcement, a spectrum of voices had begun making their case against taxpayer subsidies for oil or gas pipelines. On Thursday, Energi Media Publisher Markham Hislop opined that those subsidies are on the agenda for Martha Hall Findlay, the former Liberal MP and architect of the proposed Pathways carbon capture and storage (CCUS) hub, now the director of the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary.
In a Globe and Mail op ed May 1, Hall Findlay said it’s time to walk away from the carbon capture project she championed and just get on with building pipelines.
“Let’s reframe the effort into a better version of Pathways, one that uses its public-private and federal-provincial collaborations to support more energy production and the building, instead of a CCUS project, of a pipeline to sell more of what we have to the world.”
Hislop said that line was code for subsidies.
“It’s not much of a stretch to understand that Hall Findlay is arguing for taxpayers to wholly or in part foot the bill for another pipeline,” Hislop wrote. “The Trans Mountain Expansion cost $34 billion to build. Ottawa still owns it, despite promises to sell and recoup Canada’s investment. How much more might a new pipeline cost, given that it would traverse mountainous terrain that would be highly challenging, i.e. expensive?”
Add the cost of the new oil sands projects that would be needed to fill a new million-barrel-per-day pipeline, as envisioned in the November, 2025 Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between Canada and Alberta, and the bottom line “is so expensive that breakeven costs would make the crude uneconomic in Asia and Europe,” Hislop said.
But “who needs a business case when the Globe and Mail will print your impassioned but wrong-headed plea for public support of oil sands production and more pipelines?”
Yet public subsidies are the only way a new pipeline will happen, Stand.Earth communications officer Arin de Hoog said in an email.
“No one in the private sector is coming forward with the $35 to $40 billion it will take to finance the project,” he wrote. “This new announcement is yet another attempt to enliven market interest and show that MOU progress is being made on a pipeline that no investors want to back. Regardless of whatever Ottawa and Alberta say, the proposal is opposed by the province of B.C. and many First Nations, which means it will face the same legal challenges and protests previous pipelines have faced.”













This sounds like (yet another) plan to increase the wealth of a small number of people while the rest pf Canada foots the bill. And so terribly sad that rare and endangered species of plants and animals will pay the ultimate price, their very existence.