Both existing international law and the ongoing imperative to counter injustice and preserve human dignity demand full and enduring statehood for countries that stand to lose much or all of their land territory beneath rising seas, says a new report from the United Nations-affiliated International Law Commission (ILC).
The long-awaited report [pdf] comes seven years after the Federated States of Micronesia first asked the ILC to investigate the legal ramifications of sea level rise.
The report presents expert opinion on questions at the intersection between “the factual consequences of climate change-related sea level rise” and three core areas of international law: the law of the sea, statehood, and “the protection of persons affected by sea level rise.”
The report says it’s imperative to preserve the “integrity” of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) in the face of climate-related sea level rise.
As the fundamental legal framework that defines the rights and responsibilities of nations in their political and economic use of the world’s oceans—including territorial waters, exclusive economic zones, and the deep seabed—UNCLOS “is to be preserved and any solution relating to climate change-related sea level rise must be consistent with it,” says the ILC.
“Bringing into question maritime boundaries agreed upon or otherwise duly established under international law owing to climate change-related sea level rise would risk creating legal uncertainty and fresh disputes over maritime areas that had previously been settled.”
The ILC expressed particular concern that any pressure or move to shift territorial boundaries in response to sea level rise could imperil existing exclusive economic zones (EEZ)—the 200 nautical miles that extend outward from a coastal state’s baseline land territory within which the state has sovereign rights over marine resources—to the ultimate benefit of predatory “third States.”
The ILC also cites “widespread support” among the world’s nations “for the continuity of statehood and sovereignty and the maintenance of international legal personality” for countries that suffer physical disappearance due to sea level rise.
Rooted in countries’ right to preserve their existence and territorial integrity, and the right of their peoples to self-determination, such continuity is critical to “the maintenance of international peace and security, equity and justice, and international cooperation,” writes the ILC.
To make that continuity happen, international cooperation both on paper and in practice will be “essential,” the ILC notes.
But there’s still only limited legal protection for people affected by sea level rise, whether they’ve been displaced or are confronting impacts like salt water inundation of cropland. The ILC calls for “legal and practical solutions” to correct the current absence of a legal framework to protect affected communities.
However, the absence of a formal framework does not mean affected populations have no protection at all.
“Such persons remain rights holders and States have a duty to respect, protect, and fulfill their human rights obligations, including with regard to civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights,” the ILC writes.
The “protection of human dignity” must act as a “guiding principle” for any action undertaken to address the safety and well-being of persons affected by sea level rise, the report says, adding that everyone involved must be consulted and encouraged to participate actively in decisions that affect them.
Speaking at a recent UN oceans conference in Nice, France, international lawyer and ILC member Penelope Ridings said the world’s nations are now responsible for taking the findings of the ILC forward, reports the Guardian.
Australia is currently the leader in this space, formally recognizing as permanent the boundaries of its small island state neighbour Tuvalu, whatever the seas may do, back in 2023.











