The “grossly exaggerated if not outright false” messaging in the Alberta government’s C$8-million “Tell the Feds” ad campaign is just “a thinly disguised attempt to enlist ordinary Canadians in Alberta’s unyielding service to the fossil fuel industry,” University of Calgary law professor Martin Olszynski writes in an opinion piece for the Globe and Mail.
Everyone wants a reliable power supply, and no one is keen to “freeze in the dark”, Olszynski writes. But “independent experts have already debunked the campaign’s central claims. With some effort and planning, the transition to a cleaner power grid could actually save Canadians hundreds of dollars in power bills annually, all while providing reliable and climate-friendly electricity.”
Except that those details are hard to keep track of in an age of misinformation, Olszynski says. Rather than trying to continuously check facts and debunk myths, he advises, “Canadians should consider a government’s policy track record as a handy shortcut—especially when that government wraps its arguments in feasibility, affordability, and protecting the public purse.”
Olszynski examines that record on three fronts: Alberta’s demands for billions in federal subsidies for carbon capture and storage technologies it asserts would be infeasible under the new Clean Electricity Regulations (CER); its complaints about electricity costs under the CER when market power concentration has left the province with Canada’s highest power bills; and its failure to budget or plan for up to $260 billion in cleanup costs from oil and gas activities. That latter, massive gap “is the predictable consequence of decades of policy choices that consistently put the oil and gas industry’s desire to minimize its costs above the public interest in cleaning up wells and related infrastructure,” he writes.
Against that backdrop, “it’s no surprise that same government is unwilling to impose the costs associated with meaningful climate regulation—and will oppose such efforts from others,” Olszynski concludes. “But as year after year of extreme weather and fire seasons have made clear, climate inaction and delay come with their own significant—sometimes immeasurable—costs for the rest of us. Canadians would be justified in telling Alberta those are costs they’re no longer willing to bear.”
Read Martin Olszynski’s full line of argument here.












