The Energy Mix
Subscribe
Donate
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Energy Mix
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
Subscribe
Donate
The Energy Mix
Subscribe

Scientists, Politicians Debate Ethics of ‘Climate Tinkering’

June 7, 2022
Reading time: 5 minutes
Full Story: The Associated Press @AP
Author: Seth Borenstein @borenbears

Michael and Diane Weidner/Unsplash

Michael and Diane Weidner/Unsplash

This story includes details on the impacts of climate change that may be difficult for some readers. If you are feeling overwhelmed by this crisis situation here is a list of resources on how to cope with fears and feelings about the scope and pace of the climate crisis.

Tinkering with the planet’s air to cool Earth’s ever-warming climate is inching close enough to reality that two different high-powered groups—one consisting of scientists, the other involving former world leaders including former Canadian prime minister Kim Campbell—are trying to come up with ethics and governing guidelines.

Tomorrow, the newly-formed Climate Overshoot Commission—which includes the former presidents of Mexico, Niger, and Kiribati, the ex-head of World Trade Organization, other national minister level officials, as well as Campbell—will hold its first meeting in Italy, The Associated Press reports. That gathering will kick off a 15-month process to come up with a governance strategy for methods of pulling carbon dioxide out of the air, lowering temperatures by reflecting sunlight with artificial methods, and adapting to climate change. This month, the American Geophysical Union (AGU), the largest society of scientists who work on climate issues, announced it was developing its own ethics framework for “climate intervention” that would be ready for debate during this year’s United Nations climate conference, COP 27, in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt.

The sudden flurry of activity shows the idea of “solar geoengineering is finally getting serious,” said Harvard University climate scientist David Keith, a leader in the field.

Both groups said they aren’t quite advocating geoengineering, which includes putting particles in the air to reflect sunlight or whiten clouds, or somewhat less-disputed carbon dioxide removal, such as technology to suck carbon out of the air but also more nature-based solutions such as more trees and getting oceans to sponge up more carbon.

But the two groups say the ideas need to be discussed with global warming nearing and likely shooting past the international goal of limiting temperature increase to 1.5°C/2.7°F since preindustrial times. The world has already warmed 1.1°C/2.0°F since the mid-1800s, and scientists say the 1.5°C limit will likely be breached in the 2030s.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

“The climate change problem is at a point where even extreme options need to be thought about seriously,” Climate Overshoot Commission Executive Secretary Jesse Reynolds told AP Monday. “Now, to be clear, thinking about them includes the possibility of rejecting them. But not thinking about them does not seem to be a responsible path forward.”

What’s needed are ethical guidelines before anything is done to get the public trust, much like the scientific community did with the possibility of human cloning, said AGU Executive Director Randy Fiser. If this doesn’t happen, the public will respond with a giant backlash and won’t trust the science, said U.S. National Academy of Sciences President Marcia McNutt, who has studied the issue but declined a spot on the AGU ethics panel because of other commitments.

An earlier report by the academy “spoke to the double moral hazard of climate intervention: damned if you do, damned if you don’t,” McNutt said.

Opponents of geoengineering—such as Pennsylvania State University climate scientist Michael Mann—worry that just talking about guidelines will make the tinkering more likely to occur in the real world.

“I see it as a potentially cynical manoeuvre to buy the ostensible moral licence to move forward with dangerous geoengineering prescriptions,” Mann said in an email. He said not only could there be harmful side effects, but it takes the pressure off of cutting fossil fuel emissions, which is what’s really needed.

Mann added that no one can enforce ethics or governance rules, citing efforts to prevent Russia from invading Ukraine [and fighting a war within metres of an operating nuclear power plant—Ed.], but McNutt pointed to rules governing international oceans.

With or without guidelines, some of these high-tech ideas are going to happen, leaders of the two groups said. However, last year the Swedish government cancelled an early but politically charged test of a device designed to put particles in the air that eventually, if fully implanted, could create what some would call an artificial volcano cooling the globe temporarily like 1991’s Mt. Pinatubo eruption in the Philippines.

“The work of looking at climate strategies continues to go on in labs, both in the for-profit and non-profit sectors,” said AGU’s Fiser, with investors funneling money into such projects.

Ethicists Nancy Tuana of Penn State and Christopher Preston of the University of Montana said that, if anything, talking about the ethics of tinkering with the atmosphere will put the brakes on the effort a bit more.

“It will slow it, and this is a good thing,” Preston told AP in an email. “Ethical thresholds placed within frameworks are typically challenging to satisfy… An ethical framework can lead to paralysis. Ethics is not like maths. Ethical problems don’t often get ‘solved’.”

But not doing anything—no cuts in carbon dioxide emissions, no carbon dioxide removal, and no solar geoengineering—“that’s the worst outcome and also the path of least resistance,” said Stanford University ethics expert Hank Greely.

“I view climate intervention in the same way I view the ‘Hail Mary’ pass in football,” said Colorado University ice scientist Waleed Abdalati, a former NASA chief scientist, referring to a last-ditch desperation effort in a seemingly losing cause.

“There is a chance it could get us to where we need to be,” he said. “But just as no team wants to be in a position where that is the play they have to make, scientists recognize that we as a society would never want to be in a situation that we have to use such an approach to address the challenge we face.”

This report by the Associated Press was republished by The Canadian Press on June 6, 2022.







in CCS & Negative Emissions, Climate Equity & Justice, Research & Development

Trending Stories

More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)
Drought & Wildfires

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.3k
(File photo by Fibonacci Blue/flickr)
Climate Action

Climate Voices See Complications With Blocking New Oil and Gas

November 10, 2026
626
LNG Canada flarestack (supplied image)
Legal & Regulatory

Lawyer’s Letter Warns Pension Funds Over Potential LNG Investments

November 12, 2026
489

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

Related Articles

Senate Committee Boosts Ocean Geoengineering Technique While Calling for Further Study

Senate Committee Boosts Ocean Geoengineering Technique While Calling for Further Study

February 5, 2026
Chevron’s Gorgon CCS Plant Records Worst Performance Ever

Chevron’s Gorgon CCS Plant Records Worst Performance Ever

January 7, 2026
#Encore: Pathways CCS Project Won’t Break Even Without Efficiency Gains, Steadier Revenue: IEEFA

#Encore: Pathways CCS Project Won’t Break Even Without Efficiency Gains, Steadier Revenue: IEEFA

December 24, 2025

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

Scientists, Politicians Debate Ethics of ‘Climate Tinkering’

June 7, 2022
Reading time: 5 minutes
Full Story: The Associated Press @AP
Author: Seth Borenstein @borenbears

Michael and Diane Weidner/Unsplash

Michael and Diane Weidner/Unsplash

This story includes details on the impacts of climate change that may be difficult for some readers. If you are feeling overwhelmed by this crisis situation here is a list of resources on how to cope with fears and feelings about the scope and pace of the climate crisis.

Tinkering with the planet’s air to cool Earth’s ever-warming climate is inching close enough to reality that two different high-powered groups—one consisting of scientists, the other involving former world leaders including former Canadian prime minister Kim Campbell—are trying to come up with ethics and governing guidelines.

Tomorrow, the newly-formed Climate Overshoot Commission—which includes the former presidents of Mexico, Niger, and Kiribati, the ex-head of World Trade Organization, other national minister level officials, as well as Campbell—will hold its first meeting in Italy, The Associated Press reports. That gathering will kick off a 15-month process to come up with a governance strategy for methods of pulling carbon dioxide out of the air, lowering temperatures by reflecting sunlight with artificial methods, and adapting to climate change. This month, the American Geophysical Union (AGU), the largest society of scientists who work on climate issues, announced it was developing its own ethics framework for “climate intervention” that would be ready for debate during this year’s United Nations climate conference, COP 27, in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt.

The sudden flurry of activity shows the idea of “solar geoengineering is finally getting serious,” said Harvard University climate scientist David Keith, a leader in the field.

Both groups said they aren’t quite advocating geoengineering, which includes putting particles in the air to reflect sunlight or whiten clouds, or somewhat less-disputed carbon dioxide removal, such as technology to suck carbon out of the air but also more nature-based solutions such as more trees and getting oceans to sponge up more carbon.

But the two groups say the ideas need to be discussed with global warming nearing and likely shooting past the international goal of limiting temperature increase to 1.5°C/2.7°F since preindustrial times. The world has already warmed 1.1°C/2.0°F since the mid-1800s, and scientists say the 1.5°C limit will likely be breached in the 2030s.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

“The climate change problem is at a point where even extreme options need to be thought about seriously,” Climate Overshoot Commission Executive Secretary Jesse Reynolds told AP Monday. “Now, to be clear, thinking about them includes the possibility of rejecting them. But not thinking about them does not seem to be a responsible path forward.”

What’s needed are ethical guidelines before anything is done to get the public trust, much like the scientific community did with the possibility of human cloning, said AGU Executive Director Randy Fiser. If this doesn’t happen, the public will respond with a giant backlash and won’t trust the science, said U.S. National Academy of Sciences President Marcia McNutt, who has studied the issue but declined a spot on the AGU ethics panel because of other commitments.

An earlier report by the academy “spoke to the double moral hazard of climate intervention: damned if you do, damned if you don’t,” McNutt said.

Opponents of geoengineering—such as Pennsylvania State University climate scientist Michael Mann—worry that just talking about guidelines will make the tinkering more likely to occur in the real world.

“I see it as a potentially cynical manoeuvre to buy the ostensible moral licence to move forward with dangerous geoengineering prescriptions,” Mann said in an email. He said not only could there be harmful side effects, but it takes the pressure off of cutting fossil fuel emissions, which is what’s really needed.

Mann added that no one can enforce ethics or governance rules, citing efforts to prevent Russia from invading Ukraine [and fighting a war within metres of an operating nuclear power plant—Ed.], but McNutt pointed to rules governing international oceans.

With or without guidelines, some of these high-tech ideas are going to happen, leaders of the two groups said. However, last year the Swedish government cancelled an early but politically charged test of a device designed to put particles in the air that eventually, if fully implanted, could create what some would call an artificial volcano cooling the globe temporarily like 1991’s Mt. Pinatubo eruption in the Philippines.

“The work of looking at climate strategies continues to go on in labs, both in the for-profit and non-profit sectors,” said AGU’s Fiser, with investors funneling money into such projects.

Ethicists Nancy Tuana of Penn State and Christopher Preston of the University of Montana said that, if anything, talking about the ethics of tinkering with the atmosphere will put the brakes on the effort a bit more.

“It will slow it, and this is a good thing,” Preston told AP in an email. “Ethical thresholds placed within frameworks are typically challenging to satisfy… An ethical framework can lead to paralysis. Ethics is not like maths. Ethical problems don’t often get ‘solved’.”

But not doing anything—no cuts in carbon dioxide emissions, no carbon dioxide removal, and no solar geoengineering—“that’s the worst outcome and also the path of least resistance,” said Stanford University ethics expert Hank Greely.

“I view climate intervention in the same way I view the ‘Hail Mary’ pass in football,” said Colorado University ice scientist Waleed Abdalati, a former NASA chief scientist, referring to a last-ditch desperation effort in a seemingly losing cause.

“There is a chance it could get us to where we need to be,” he said. “But just as no team wants to be in a position where that is the play they have to make, scientists recognize that we as a society would never want to be in a situation that we have to use such an approach to address the challenge we face.”

This report by the Associated Press was republished by The Canadian Press on June 6, 2022.







in CCS & Negative Emissions, Climate Equity & Justice, Research & Development

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Related Articles

Senate Committee Boosts Ocean Geoengineering Technique While Calling for Further Study

Senate Committee Boosts Ocean Geoengineering Technique While Calling for Further Study

February 5, 2026
Chevron’s Gorgon CCS Plant Records Worst Performance Ever

Chevron’s Gorgon CCS Plant Records Worst Performance Ever

January 7, 2026
#Encore: Pathways CCS Project Won’t Break Even Without Efficiency Gains, Steadier Revenue: IEEFA

#Encore: Pathways CCS Project Won’t Break Even Without Efficiency Gains, Steadier Revenue: IEEFA

December 24, 2025

Trending Stories

More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.3k
(File photo by Fibonacci Blue/flickr)

Climate Voices See Complications With Blocking New Oil and Gas

November 10, 2026
626
LNG Canada flarestack (supplied image)

Lawyer’s Letter Warns Pension Funds Over Potential LNG Investments

November 12, 2026
489

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

Copyright 2026 © Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy and Copyright
  • Cookie Policy
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.