The Energy Mix
Subscribe
Donate
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
    • Climate Glossary
    • What If We Changed the Conversation on Climate Change?
    • Eco-Anxiety
  • About
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Energy Mix
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
    • Climate Glossary
    • What If We Changed the Conversation on Climate Change?
    • Eco-Anxiety
  • About
  • Contact
Subscribe
Donate
The Energy Mix
Subscribe

Science splits ranks over fossil fuel phase-out

June 26, 2017
Reading time: 4 minutes
Author: Tim Radford

US academics are arguing with ferocity about how to achieve a fossil fuel phase out. But, for now, the debate is entirely academic.

LONDON, 26 June, 2017 – In a furious argument that can only leave the lay observer  blinking, two sets of academics have parted company over the future of US energy: how actually to achieve a fossil fuel phase-out.

One group has just published a complex analysis that bundles together wind, sun and hydro power, the nuclear option, biofuels and even carbon capture and storage (CCS) as the realistic answer to the need to drastically reduce a nation’s reliance on fossil fuels.

And the other group thinks the US can be powered by wind turbines, hydropower and photovoltaic cells.

To complicate matters, last year the lead author of the first group seemed also to think the same thing. Christopher Clack of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration in Boulder, Colorado, went on record then with a proposal that could deliver clean power to all 50 US states.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

Diversity needed

But the latest study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, argues that only “a diverse portfolio of clean energy technologies makes a transition to low-carbon-emission strategy both more feasible and less costly than other pathways.”

This is, the study says, in contrast to a study led by a scientist at Stanford University who said it could all be done by wind, water and solar power.

And just to ram home the point, Dr Clack and colleagues find “significant shortcomings” in the Stanford analysis.

Their paper is accompanied by a short, fierce response in the same journal from Mark Jacobson of Stanford, cited in the first study, who argues that the premise of Clack and his colleagues is “demonstrably false.”

Counter argument

On the contrary, Professor Jacobson’s arguments are, Professor Jacobson says, “in the mainstream, as grid stability studies finding low-cost, up-to-100% clean renewable solutions without nuclear or CCS are in the majority.”

That is, he and his partners stand by their argument: America could power itself by renewable technologies.

He is not the first to make such a claim: researchers at the University of Delaware long ago proposed that renewable energy could provide 99.9% of the national electricity supply.

Although US President Trump has torn up the nation’s promise to contain global warming, and invoked coal as a key part of his energy strategy, other studies have pointed out that coal is a bad bargain: the US would gain far more in human health, lives saved and return on investment if it put the money into renewables such as solar power.

“Our energy system is leaking waste carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. When you call a plumber to fix a leak, you want her to arrive with a full toolbox”

To the interested lay reader, the academic furore seems for the moment entirely theoretical: on the face of it neither side of the argument is likely in the near future to see its hypothesis tested in the energy market.

But at bottom there remains a serious problem. On the assumption that global warming is not a hoax invented by the Chinese to cripple the US economy – and only President Trump has made that claim – then the issue will become a matter of national urgency as sea levels rise, floods, droughts and superstorms become more frequent, and some Americans have to abandon their homes as climate refugees.

So the question raised by what might seem an academic dogfight remains open: how do modern economies get to a state in which they can drastically reduce dependence on fossil fuels? And the case made by Clack and his colleagues is that researchers should be looking at every possible option to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

“Our energy system is leaking waste carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. When you call a plumber to fix a leak, you want her to arrive with a full toolbox and not leave most of her tools at home,” Ken Caldeira, of the Carnegie Institution for Science and one of the authors, said. “Having a full toolbox means you are more likely to be able to solve the problem.” – Climate News Network







in Climate News Network

Trending Stories

(Julie Dabrusin/Facebook)
Carbon Pricing

EXCLUSIVE: Carbon Tax Exemption for Canada Would Break World Trade Rules, EU Law

November 3, 2026
1.6k
Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne at 2025 Collision Conferencef/flickr
Finance & Investment

Federal Budget Funds Clean Grid and Energy Efficiency, Touts ‘Investment Supercycle’ Built on Major Projects

November 6, 2026
749
Alberta Environment and Protected Areas Minister Grant Hunter, Alberta Newsroom/flickr
Legal & Regulatory

Alberta Accused of Rushing Environmental Law Changes Behind Closed Doors

November 5, 2026
732

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

Actions Speak Louder Than Words

by Mitchell Beer
November 2, 2026

…

Follow Us

Science splits ranks over fossil fuel phase-out

June 26, 2017
Reading time: 4 minutes
Author: Tim Radford

US academics are arguing with ferocity about how to achieve a fossil fuel phase out. But, for now, the debate is entirely academic.

LONDON, 26 June, 2017 – In a furious argument that can only leave the lay observer  blinking, two sets of academics have parted company over the future of US energy: how actually to achieve a fossil fuel phase-out.

One group has just published a complex analysis that bundles together wind, sun and hydro power, the nuclear option, biofuels and even carbon capture and storage (CCS) as the realistic answer to the need to drastically reduce a nation’s reliance on fossil fuels.

And the other group thinks the US can be powered by wind turbines, hydropower and photovoltaic cells.

To complicate matters, last year the lead author of the first group seemed also to think the same thing. Christopher Clack of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration in Boulder, Colorado, went on record then with a proposal that could deliver clean power to all 50 US states.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

Diversity needed

But the latest study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, argues that only “a diverse portfolio of clean energy technologies makes a transition to low-carbon-emission strategy both more feasible and less costly than other pathways.”

This is, the study says, in contrast to a study led by a scientist at Stanford University who said it could all be done by wind, water and solar power.

And just to ram home the point, Dr Clack and colleagues find “significant shortcomings” in the Stanford analysis.

Their paper is accompanied by a short, fierce response in the same journal from Mark Jacobson of Stanford, cited in the first study, who argues that the premise of Clack and his colleagues is “demonstrably false.”

Counter argument

On the contrary, Professor Jacobson’s arguments are, Professor Jacobson says, “in the mainstream, as grid stability studies finding low-cost, up-to-100% clean renewable solutions without nuclear or CCS are in the majority.”

That is, he and his partners stand by their argument: America could power itself by renewable technologies.

He is not the first to make such a claim: researchers at the University of Delaware long ago proposed that renewable energy could provide 99.9% of the national electricity supply.

Although US President Trump has torn up the nation’s promise to contain global warming, and invoked coal as a key part of his energy strategy, other studies have pointed out that coal is a bad bargain: the US would gain far more in human health, lives saved and return on investment if it put the money into renewables such as solar power.

“Our energy system is leaking waste carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. When you call a plumber to fix a leak, you want her to arrive with a full toolbox”

To the interested lay reader, the academic furore seems for the moment entirely theoretical: on the face of it neither side of the argument is likely in the near future to see its hypothesis tested in the energy market.

But at bottom there remains a serious problem. On the assumption that global warming is not a hoax invented by the Chinese to cripple the US economy – and only President Trump has made that claim – then the issue will become a matter of national urgency as sea levels rise, floods, droughts and superstorms become more frequent, and some Americans have to abandon their homes as climate refugees.

So the question raised by what might seem an academic dogfight remains open: how do modern economies get to a state in which they can drastically reduce dependence on fossil fuels? And the case made by Clack and his colleagues is that researchers should be looking at every possible option to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

“Our energy system is leaking waste carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. When you call a plumber to fix a leak, you want her to arrive with a full toolbox and not leave most of her tools at home,” Ken Caldeira, of the Carnegie Institution for Science and one of the authors, said. “Having a full toolbox means you are more likely to be able to solve the problem.” – Climate News Network







in Climate News Network

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Trending Stories

(Julie Dabrusin/Facebook)

EXCLUSIVE: Carbon Tax Exemption for Canada Would Break World Trade Rules, EU Law

November 3, 2026
1.6k
Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne at 2025 Collision Conferencef/flickr

Federal Budget Funds Clean Grid and Energy Efficiency, Touts ‘Investment Supercycle’ Built on Major Projects

November 6, 2026
749
Alberta Environment and Protected Areas Minister Grant Hunter, Alberta Newsroom/flickr

Alberta Accused of Rushing Environmental Law Changes Behind Closed Doors

November 5, 2026
732

Actions Speak Louder Than Words

by Mitchell Beer
November 2, 2026

…

Follow Us

Copyright 2026 © Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy and Copyright
  • Cookie Policy
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
    • Climate Glossary
    • What If We Changed the Conversation on Climate Change?
    • Eco-Anxiety
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
    • Climate Glossary
    • What If We Changed the Conversation on Climate Change?
    • Eco-Anxiety
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.