The Energy Mix
Subscribe
Donate
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Energy Mix
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
Subscribe
Donate
The Energy Mix
Subscribe

Ottawa to Appeal After Alberta’s Top Court Rules Against Impact Assessment Act

May 11, 2022
Reading time: 3 minutes
Full Story: The Canadian Press @CdnPressNews with file from The Energy Mix
Author: Colette Derowiz

EcoFlight

EcoFlight

Alberta’s top court said Tuesday the federal government’s environmental impact law is unconstitutional, and Ottawa almost immediately announced its plan to appeal.

The Alberta Court of Appeal called the Impact Assessment Act is an “existential threat” to the division of powers guaranteed by the Constitution, The Canadian Press reports.

In the House of Commons later, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said the law delivered on a promise to reform a “broken system and restore public trust in how decisions about major projects are made,” adding that “we will be appealing this decision.”

The Alberta government, calling it a Trojan Horse, had challenged the law over what the province argued was an overreach into provincial powers.

The act, given royal assent in 2019, lists activities that trigger an impact review and allows Ottawa to consider the effects of new resource projects on a range of environmental and social issues, including climate change. Alberta argued the law could use those concerns to greatly expand the range of federal oversight into areas of provincial jurisdiction.

A majority of five justices, giving their legal opinion in a 204-page document released Tuesday, sided with Alberta.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

“Climate change constitutes an existential threat to Canada,” Chief Justice Catherine Fraser and two others wrote.

But “the (Impact Assessment Act) involves another existential threat—one also pressing and consequential—and that is the clear and present danger this legislative scheme presents to the division of powers guaranteed by our Constitution and, thus, to Canada itself.”

The opinion added that legitimate concerns about the environment and climate change should not override the division of power. “If the federal government believes otherwise, it should make the case for an increase in its jurisdiction to the Canadian public.”

A fourth judge signed off on that opinion with the exception of one section.

In a dissenting opinion, Justice Sheila Greckol said the federal environmental impact law is a valid exercise of constitutional authority.

“The federal environmental assessment regime prohibits projects that may have effects in federal jurisdiction—on fish and fish habitat, aquatic species, migratory birds, on federal lands or federally funded projects, between provinces, outside Canada, and with respect to Indigenous peoples,” she wrote.

“The complexities and the urgency of the climate crisis call for co-operative interlocking environmental protection regimes among multiple jurisdictions, each functioning at its highest and best within their constitutional jurisdiction.”

Now is not the time to “give credence to any kind of ‘Trojan Horse’ metaphor advanced by Alberta and Saskatchewan,” Greckol wrote. “Likening Canada to a foreign invading army deceptively breaching our protective walls only fuels suspicion and pits one level of government against each other.”

There were 17 interveners in the case, CP says.

Alberta was supported in its challenge by the governments of Saskatchewan and Ontario, as well as three First Nations and the Indian Resource Council.

Seven of the interveners, including a wide array of environmental and legal groups as well as other First Nations, were in support of Ottawa.

“People across Canada—including in Alberta—deserve a robust environmental planning process that safeguards the long-term health of our communities while allowing good projects to be built,” Julia Levin, national climate program manager at Environmental Defence Canada, said in a release Tuesday.

“Provincial governments should be cooperating with the federal government to protect the environment and tackle the climate crisis, not making it easier for resource extraction companies to decimate the land, air, and water by attacking federal laws.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 10, 2022.







in Biodiversity & Habitat, Canada, Climate Equity & Justice, Energy Politics, Health & Safety, Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation, Legal & Regulatory, Oil & Gas, Oil Sands, Subnational

Trending Stories

More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)
Drought & Wildfires

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.3k
(File photo by Fibonacci Blue/flickr)
Climate Action

Climate Voices See Complications With Blocking New Oil and Gas

November 10, 2026
631
LNG Canada flarestack (supplied image)
Legal & Regulatory

Lawyer’s Letter Warns Pension Funds Over Potential LNG Investments

November 12, 2026
494

Comments 2

  1. Dave Murray says:
    5 years ago

    That is a a disingenuous photo to use to describe this article. It is an aerial photo of US well sites taken in 2006. It is not representative of Canadian drilling, nor of current extraction techniques. You are simply trying to use the photo to throw raw-meat on this issue.

    Reply
    • Mitchell Beer says:
      5 years ago

      Seriously. A watered down, only episodically effective impact assessment act is hyperbolically described as a “Trojan Horse” threatening Canadian democracy, and we’re the ones throwing raw meat?

      TBH, we hadn’t realized the photo was from Wyoming until you pointed that out, so many thanks for the heads-up. But fracking is still very much a live issue for impact assessment, and we can expect that it will be for longer than some other forms of fossil fuel production that will likely die out faster. If you know of any equivalent public domain photos from the fracking fields in northeastern British Columbia, for example, we’ll be happy to drop them in as a replacement.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

Related Articles

New Report Guides Canadian Firms Through Climate Transition Planning

New Report Guides Canadian Firms Through Climate Transition Planning

February 4, 2026
Pakistan Seeks Justice for Environmental Harm Through Climate Litigation

Pakistan Seeks Justice for Environmental Harm Through Climate Litigation

January 21, 2026
Judge Rejects Legal Challenge to Saskatchewan Coal Extension

Judge Rejects Legal Challenge to Saskatchewan Coal Extension

January 19, 2026

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

Ottawa to Appeal After Alberta’s Top Court Rules Against Impact Assessment Act

May 11, 2022
Reading time: 3 minutes
Full Story: The Canadian Press @CdnPressNews with file from The Energy Mix
Author: Colette Derowiz

EcoFlight

EcoFlight

Alberta’s top court said Tuesday the federal government’s environmental impact law is unconstitutional, and Ottawa almost immediately announced its plan to appeal.

The Alberta Court of Appeal called the Impact Assessment Act is an “existential threat” to the division of powers guaranteed by the Constitution, The Canadian Press reports.

In the House of Commons later, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said the law delivered on a promise to reform a “broken system and restore public trust in how decisions about major projects are made,” adding that “we will be appealing this decision.”

The Alberta government, calling it a Trojan Horse, had challenged the law over what the province argued was an overreach into provincial powers.

The act, given royal assent in 2019, lists activities that trigger an impact review and allows Ottawa to consider the effects of new resource projects on a range of environmental and social issues, including climate change. Alberta argued the law could use those concerns to greatly expand the range of federal oversight into areas of provincial jurisdiction.

A majority of five justices, giving their legal opinion in a 204-page document released Tuesday, sided with Alberta.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

“Climate change constitutes an existential threat to Canada,” Chief Justice Catherine Fraser and two others wrote.

But “the (Impact Assessment Act) involves another existential threat—one also pressing and consequential—and that is the clear and present danger this legislative scheme presents to the division of powers guaranteed by our Constitution and, thus, to Canada itself.”

The opinion added that legitimate concerns about the environment and climate change should not override the division of power. “If the federal government believes otherwise, it should make the case for an increase in its jurisdiction to the Canadian public.”

A fourth judge signed off on that opinion with the exception of one section.

In a dissenting opinion, Justice Sheila Greckol said the federal environmental impact law is a valid exercise of constitutional authority.

“The federal environmental assessment regime prohibits projects that may have effects in federal jurisdiction—on fish and fish habitat, aquatic species, migratory birds, on federal lands or federally funded projects, between provinces, outside Canada, and with respect to Indigenous peoples,” she wrote.

“The complexities and the urgency of the climate crisis call for co-operative interlocking environmental protection regimes among multiple jurisdictions, each functioning at its highest and best within their constitutional jurisdiction.”

Now is not the time to “give credence to any kind of ‘Trojan Horse’ metaphor advanced by Alberta and Saskatchewan,” Greckol wrote. “Likening Canada to a foreign invading army deceptively breaching our protective walls only fuels suspicion and pits one level of government against each other.”

There were 17 interveners in the case, CP says.

Alberta was supported in its challenge by the governments of Saskatchewan and Ontario, as well as three First Nations and the Indian Resource Council.

Seven of the interveners, including a wide array of environmental and legal groups as well as other First Nations, were in support of Ottawa.

“People across Canada—including in Alberta—deserve a robust environmental planning process that safeguards the long-term health of our communities while allowing good projects to be built,” Julia Levin, national climate program manager at Environmental Defence Canada, said in a release Tuesday.

“Provincial governments should be cooperating with the federal government to protect the environment and tackle the climate crisis, not making it easier for resource extraction companies to decimate the land, air, and water by attacking federal laws.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 10, 2022.







in Biodiversity & Habitat, Canada, Climate Equity & Justice, Energy Politics, Health & Safety, Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation, Legal & Regulatory, Oil & Gas, Oil Sands, Subnational

Comments 2

  1. Dave Murray says:
    5 years ago

    That is a a disingenuous photo to use to describe this article. It is an aerial photo of US well sites taken in 2006. It is not representative of Canadian drilling, nor of current extraction techniques. You are simply trying to use the photo to throw raw-meat on this issue.

    Reply
    • Mitchell Beer says:
      5 years ago

      Seriously. A watered down, only episodically effective impact assessment act is hyperbolically described as a “Trojan Horse” threatening Canadian democracy, and we’re the ones throwing raw meat?

      TBH, we hadn’t realized the photo was from Wyoming until you pointed that out, so many thanks for the heads-up. But fracking is still very much a live issue for impact assessment, and we can expect that it will be for longer than some other forms of fossil fuel production that will likely die out faster. If you know of any equivalent public domain photos from the fracking fields in northeastern British Columbia, for example, we’ll be happy to drop them in as a replacement.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Related Articles

New Report Guides Canadian Firms Through Climate Transition Planning

New Report Guides Canadian Firms Through Climate Transition Planning

February 4, 2026
Pakistan Seeks Justice for Environmental Harm Through Climate Litigation

Pakistan Seeks Justice for Environmental Harm Through Climate Litigation

January 21, 2026
Judge Rejects Legal Challenge to Saskatchewan Coal Extension

Judge Rejects Legal Challenge to Saskatchewan Coal Extension

January 19, 2026

Trending Stories

More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.3k
(File photo by Fibonacci Blue/flickr)

Climate Voices See Complications With Blocking New Oil and Gas

November 10, 2026
631
LNG Canada flarestack (supplied image)

Lawyer’s Letter Warns Pension Funds Over Potential LNG Investments

November 12, 2026
494

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

Copyright 2026 © Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy and Copyright
  • Cookie Policy
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.