The Ontario government’s latest legislative effort to accelerate housing starts has received a failing grade from a suite of climate, housing, and affordability experts, including former Toronto mayor David Miller.
Tabled less than a year after the Protect Ontario by Building Faster and Smarter Act and the Fighting Delays, Building Faster Act, and now in its second reading, the proposed Building Homes and Improving Transportation Infrastructure Act(Bill 98) promises to “reduce barriers to homebuilding and increase economic efficiency by creating a simplified and standardized format for official plans and clarifying and streamlining site plan rules,” according to a recent media briefing [pdf].
Such “standardization” and “streamlining” are declared to be in the public interest, designed to “advance the government’s plan to protect Ontario by building a stronger and more self-reliant province.”
The language of the Bill 98 doesn’t match up with its claim to be protecting the common good, said Miller, now managing director of the C40 Centre, which brings together mayors, city officials, economists, and academics around climate response.
“It’s clear that this legislation is attempting to greatly weaken the environmental protections that cities and towns developed because the people who live there demanded them,” Miller told The Energy Mix in an interview.
Should Bill 98 [pdf] become law, municipal official plans will “no longer [be] required to contain goals, objectives, and actions to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions and to provide for adaptation to a changing climate,” in the words of a proposed amendment to Ontario’s Planning Act.
Bill 98 also proposes to repeal sections of the province’s Municipal Act which authorize more than 15 Ontario municipalities to use green development standards, like high-efficiency heating and cooling, to ensure resilient and energy-efficient buildings. Equivalent sections of the City of Toronto Act—and its much-lauded Toronto Green Standard—are also on the chopping block.
Those changes would run roughshod over ever-deepening public recognition that “well-insulated, properly built apartments and houses are healthier, more comfortable, and far cheaper to live in,” Miller said.
Miller isn’t the only one raising the alarm.
Affordability, Climate Safety, and Ideas That Work
“We are concerned that Bill 98 undermines municipalities’ abilities to manage growth in a sustainable way, or to protect energy affordability, public health, and climate objectives,” Bryan Purcell, vice president of policy and programs at the Toronto Atmospheric Fund (TAF), writes in a media release.
Removing or disabling green development standards “risks setting back progress towards sustainable buildings by a decade,” he adds, while doing “little if anything to accelerate housing development.”
While the province is touting Bill 98 as a highway to greater “self-reliance” for all Ontarians, TAF is warning of steep tolls ahead.
“By proposing rolling back cost-effective energy efficiency and resilience standards, Bill 98 increases the likelihood that buildings will default to gas heating,” a “regression” that will “deepen Ontario’s reliance on imported U.S. natural gas, undermining our energy independence and leaving the province more exposed to volatile fossil fuel prices and trade disruptions.”
And the public will pay the price, Purcell adds. “When new homes aren’t built to meet high energy standards, the people of Ontario end up paying more for heating, cooling, and electricity over the building’s lifetime.”
The Toronto Environmental Alliance (TEA) is likewise warning that Bill 98 stands to make Ontario families more insecure.
The Ford government is “attacking local climate-safe building rules again at the worst possible time—just as fuel prices are rising and we start facing another season of floods, fire, and extreme heat,” TEA Campaigns Director Sarah Buchanan said in a release.
Writing in the wake of the Ford government’s unilateral repeal of the Green Roof Bylaw last October, sustainable design experts writing in Canadian Architect warned against any further erosion in municipal powers to enforce sustainable development standards.
“Municipal green development standards exist because they are practical, measurable and effective,” Jeanne Ng, Lisa Prime, and Michelle Xuereb wrote late last year.
“If these standards become voluntary, we risk eroding the quality of our city spaces just when we need it most.”
Local Governance, Public Engagement Under Threat
Climate and housing advocates are also concerned that the amendments contained in Bill 98 will leave municipal leaders and their constituents increasingly disconnected from the local realities that ground, and shape, policy.
“Effective community planning depends on understanding local conditions—including infrastructure capacity, environmental constraints, and the needs of residents,” TAF’s Bryan Purcell told The Mix in an email. “Municipal governments are best positioned to assess and balance these factors.”
Responding to the Ford government’s claim that Bill 98 will bring long overdue “standardization” to the planning process, TAF said municipalities already have this key element well in hand after spending the past decade “harmonizing green development standards to provide predictability for builders while maintaining quality housing.”
TAF adds that “reducing the scope for local decision‑making weakens opportunities for residents to participate in shaping growth and development in their communities—a key component of transparent, accountable planning.”
‘Clear Ground’ to Oppose the Bill
“The public and all Ontario MPPs have clear and substantive ground to oppose significant portions of [Bill 98],” concludes Ballard Advisory Group Principal Chris Ballard, whose past provincial cabinet posts included environment and climate change, housing, and poverty reduction.
The removal of mandatory climate change planning from municipal official plans is the worst part of the proposed legislation, Ballard writes on LinkedIn. “No government can credibly claim to be ‘building strong communities’ while stripping the very tools municipalities use to plan for climate resilience.”
The move to “gut” green development standards sidesteps the “downstream costs taxpayers will bear in flood damage, heat emergencies, and aging infrastructure,” and cannot be allowed to pass, he adds.
Miller urged all Ontarians to speak up against the “quite nefarious” efforts by the Ford government to “interfere with local autonomy.”
“Around the world, we’re seeing a rise of populist governments, and part of that is due to people feeling disengaged and disenfranchised from policy decisions that affect their lives,” Miller told The Mix.
“The remedy to that is open, public decision-making that includes them,” he added. “That’s why we have green development standards across a lot of places in the province, because people spoke up.”
The Environmental Registry of Ontario portal is taking comments on the bill until April 29 at noon.












