As the Alberta government advances a proposal to treat toxic oil sands tailings stored in massive ponds and eventually release the treated water into the Athabasca River, nearby Indigenous nations are denouncing the plan as a threat to their communities and calling for stronger federal oversight.
“This province works backwards,” Chief Allan Adam of Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation (AFCN) said in a statement. “The oil industry has been unregulated for decades, which has allowed them to create huge lakes of toxic waste. ACFN is not planning to sit back and let them try to regulate their way out of this mess without our approval.”
Oil sands tailings are a mix of water, sand, clay, and chemical residues left after bitumen is separated from the sands. These materials, considered toxic to fish and other wildlife, are stored in large tailings ponds that now cover more than 300 square kilometres in northern Alberta. The water from the ponds can be partially recycled after sitting in the pond to let heavier sediments settle to the bottom, but the volume continues to accumulate without a safe way of releasing it.
Technologies do exist that can treat the water to drinking-water standards, but they are costly and not considered viable at the current scale, writes CBC News. But the tailings cannot be stored indefinitely. Experts warn that the longer the ponds remain in place—and the more they expand—the greater the risk of leaks or structural failures that could release untreated tailings into surrounding ecosystems.
Tailings ponds from oil sands mines in northern Alberta store about 1.4 trillion litres of this waste water, and seepage has already been identified, with harmful impacts on surrounding communities, reports The Canadian Press. Tailings have leaked into the Athabasca watershed from Imperial Oil’s Kearl oil sands mine since at least 2019, contaminating waters and hunting areas used by the Mikisew Cree and the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nations.
The Alberta government says it is essential to find a way to treat and release tailings back into the watershed to reduce the risks of future leaks. An Oil Sands Mine Water Steering Committee released 21 recommendations for doing so earlier this year.
Then on October 2, Alberta Premiere Danielle Smith issued a mandate letter to the Minister of Environment and Protected Areas, calling for “finalizing and publicly releasing a final accelerated strategy for oil sands mine water management and tailings pond reclamation.”
The energy and minerals ministry told CBC News it is moving forward with 20 of the 21 recommendations, but did not clarify which one is not being adopted.
Indigenous groups are protesting the plan to release treated tailings back into the watershed, reports Fort McMurray Today. Mikisew Cree First Nation Chief Billy-Joe Tuccaro said in a statement that the technologies for treating tailings water are unproven, and that releasing them into a waterway that is a crucial resource for the Nation is “unacceptable.”
“We have seen elevated cancer in our community already, this will only make it worse,” he said. “Our peoples’ lives are at stake, and the government of Alberta must act.”
Non-profit Indigenous Climate Action says the situation highlights the need for federal leadership on the issue. The Mining Association of Canada too told CBC News it has been asking the federal government to take action for the past 15 years. Last August, then-environment minister Stephen Guilbeault said solutions other than treating and releasing the tailings were being considered.
The federal government does already facilitate a Crown-Indigenous Working Group to discuss Indigenous communities’ concerns about releasing treated tailings into the Athabasca River. The group published a discussion paper in February that did not result in defined federal actions, but stated that “completion of work on alternatives to release of treated effluent and a draft regulatory framework is targeted for the end of 2025.”
The Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation, Mikisew Cree First Nation, and Fort McKay First Nation have also commissioned their own study to define technical standards to ensure water quality from treated tailings.










First, mining of the Tar Sands must be stopped. Then, by whatever means, the tailings ponds should be converted into Sphagnum-based bogs, to try to recapture as peat some of the carbon dioxide the Tar Sand Debacle has released.