Opposition is mounting in New Brunswick—and spreading to Ottawa—over a proposed 500-megawatt gas-and-diesel power plant in rural Tantramar, a multi-billion-dollar project that could push utility bills up by almost 5%.
Op-eds published by NB Media Co-op capture the public’s discontent, with headlines calling it “a deal New Brunswick can’t afford” and arguing the province’s main utility NB Power “has failed to make its case” for a new fossil fuel project without evaluating the alternatives.
On March 11, federal Green Party Leader Elizabeth May tabled a petition in Parliament with 1,150 signatures, calling for a “full, independent environmental and climate impact assessment” of the project and for the low-lying Chignecto Isthmus, where the plant is proposed, to be designated a federally protected area. The narrow land mass connecting Nova Scotia to the Canadian mainland is under extreme threat from climate change and was identified by experts as particularly vulnerable to sea level rise, May said. The petition was started by Midgic resident Kristen LeBlanc and May agreed to bring it to Ottawa, reported the Telegraph Journal, adding that the federal impact assessment agency had issued a decision last September stating “no further assessment is required” for the plant.
The controversy surrounds the Renewable Integration and Grid Security (RIGS) project, a 500-megawatt gas and diesel dual-use turbine power facility slated for Centre Village, a town in the rural area of Tantramar. NB Power selected Missouri-based ProEnergy to develop the project following a request for expressions of interest. The facility is expected to start operating in late 2028.
A recent RIGS project update states it is undergoing a provincial environmental impact assessment, and that the facility will help cut grid emissions by displacing coal.
Though ProEnergy had previously indicated that the North Shore Mi’kmaq Tribal Council was a minor equity partner in the project, documents released by NB Power showed that was not the case, reported CBC News. Additional reporting shows that while the Tribal Council expressed support for the project, no deal has yet been made, and the Council says that community support cannot be guaranteed.
The Tribal Council is also undertaking its own assessment of the project. Dean Vicaire, executive director of Mi’gmawe’l Tplu’taqnn Inc., the consultative body for eight of the nine Mi’kmaw nations in the province, told CBC that the assessment will “take a good hard look” at the potential consequences of the proposal.
Residents and community groups including the Conservation Council of New Brunswick have pushed back on the project over concerns about greenhouse gas emissions, cost, noise and light pollution, and other environmental impacts. NB Power maintains the project is the most economical solution to meet growing power demand. The utility says the province could face a 600-megawatt supply shortfall as early as 2030, reports Global News.
“(We) faced a lot of criticism around the RIGS project simply because of the speed and pace the project is moving, and my answer to that is we were on a highway and the signpost is coming at us at 100 miles an hour,” said Brad Coady, NB Power’s chief commercial officer, at an Energy and Utilities board hearing.
Proponents say the facility will serve as “a ‘shock absorber’ for the electricity grid” to smooth “the effects of sudden changes in wind and solar generation output.”
However, residents have decried a lack of transparency, particularly around the project’s cost, for which developers have yet to provide a firm estimate. At a recent Energy and Utilities Board hearing, Coady said estimates price it at over C$1 billion.
But CBC News writes that Alain Chiasson, a provincially-appointed intervenor representing the public’s interest, said his rough math suggests a higher cost. Chiasson said he multiplied a $142-million annual revenue requirement—mentioned in an April, 2024 NB Power briefing note—by 25 years, to estimate a total cost of $3.5 billion. Although NB Power officials said the math would not be “quite that simple,” Andrew Secord, a professor and economist at St. Thomas University, said the result is a “solid ballpark figure” that can help inform the public and ratepayers.
NB Power has reached a deal to sell Nova Scotia’s Independent Energy System Operator 100 megawatts from RIGS over the next 10 years, which could help cut down costs, writes CBC News.
NB Power has estimated that the project would increase rates for its customers by 4.98%, though Fredericton’s Daily Gleaner reports that estimate is still uncertain. Another estimate commissioned by Chiasson suggests the increase would be lower—around 4%—but he still isn’t in favour of the facility, adding that NB Power should look at more alternatives, like battery energy storage systems.
In the project update, RIGS estimates that a battery project capable of powering the province for a day would cost tens of billions of dollars. [But battery storage systems are typically designed to store electricity when it’s cheap and release it when demand is at its peak, not to run a full day—Ed.]
In January, New Brunswick Premier Susan Holt said she was looking into alternative sites for the project due to the community resistance. In February, more than 120 scientists and academics from all four universities in New Brunswick wrote Holt an open letter calling the gas plant proposal “scientifically, environmentally, and economically nonsensical”. They pointed to wind turbines, solar power, battery systems, and demand management as cheaper, faster solutions to meet rising power demand.













We have in Nova Scotia the same process, in somewhat slower motion. But with our government talking to ProPower even earlier than they peddled this turkey to NB Power. Two plants here. And the government deliberately keeping battery storage out of the RFP process, so that the gas plants dont get rigorous regulatory cost comparison to that option.