Canada’s rollback of its anti-greenwashing rules may leave some business concerns unresolved while risking an overcorrection, a legal expert says.
Bill C-59, enacted in 2024, had been hailed by many environmental groups as a step toward curbing misleading environmental claims. But last year, Prime Minister Mark Carney announced that the government would scale back key parts of the law, including the requirement that environmental benefit claims be backed by internationally recognized methodology, and the ability for third parties to bring cases before the Competition Tribunal.
There is an issue “when companies are concerned about litigation risk, real or perceived,” Helen Tooze, a senior policy researcher for the Canada Climate Law Initiative (CCLI), told The Energy Mix.
CCLI is “not 100% happy” with the changes, Tooze added. The original bill had its flaws, but the new changes may be going “too far in the other direction.”
Bill C-59 was introduced amid widespread concerns that businesses were overstating the environmental benefits of their products or operations, using terms like “sustainable” or “net-zero,” without clear oversight. The legislation updated the federal Competition Act to give the Competition Bureau new powers to hold businesses accountable, including requirements that environmental statements about a product are based on “adequate and proper” testing, and that representation about a business or its activity is backed up by internationally recognized methodologies.
Both requirements carried a “reverse onus,” meaning a defendant company, when challenged, carried the burden of substantiating its claims, rather than requiring complainants to prove they were misleading. The law also opened the door for private parties to bring forward greenwashing allegations, potentially exposing companies to reputational risks, even if they were to win the case in the end.
Businesses raised concerns about how these amendments would affect their ability to confidently make environmental claims—a matter included in a constitutional challenge to Bill C-59 before Alberta courts. According to CCLI, businesses said the bill would prohibit “a range of expression” about environmental representations, including those that are “true, reasonable, or defensible in light of the known evidence,” have a “chilling effect” that discourages businesses from expressing environmental information, and place “extraordinary reverse onus” requirements on a company to support its environmental representations against “vague and uncertain standards of verification” for future impacts and intentions that aren’t provable ahead of time.
Several corporations rolled back some of their environmental claims, including the Pathways Alliance, the Royal Bank of Canada, and the Canadian Public Pension Plan Investment Board. Defenders of the legislation said the reaction demonstrated that the anti-greenwashing provisions were serving their purpose, but Tooze said Bill C-59 could pose a legal risk to companies with good intentions.
Bill C-59 also left uncertainty about which environmental statements the law would apply to. Advertising to consumers was surely within its scope, but what about statements made to investors, or in securities filings? Competition Bureau guidance later clarified that the amendments would not pertain to securities filings, but Tooze said statements to investors remained in a “gray area.” Some investors have reportedly communicated to CCLI that they were unable to receive sustainability information from businesses following Bill C-59’s enactment, though Tooze would not share specific names.
Supporters of the bill say the rules put necessary pressure on companies and should not raise alarm if a business’s environmental claims are backed up. Wren Montgomery opines in Corporate Knights that “greenhushing” indicates a company is “walking the walk,” which is preferable to them just “talking the talk.” CCLI suggests that companies should be careful of how they represent their products and actions, but also ensure they are engaging in real climate actions rather than being fearful of making claims.
Still, concerns about the uncertainty surrounding the bill are shared across ideological fault lines. In written consultation responses regarding the legislation, the Canadian Renewable Energy Association called for specific parameters for the “adequate and proper testing” requirement, which will have significant operational and financial implications for the group’s members “who deploy a variety of wind, solar, and energy storage technologies.” The association also called for a screening process to moderate reverse onus allegations and protect small and medium businesses from costly lawsuits, and for clarity about what materials the law is applied to so that “good actors are not discouraged from informing consumers of the environmental benefits of their products.”
Enwave, a Canadian district energy business, also requested more clarification about terminology and guidelines for “adequate and proper testing,” and the conservation organization Ducks Unlimited asked for similar clarifications as well as an explicit exemptions for not-for-profit organizations.
The comments were submitted prior to guidance that the Competition Bureau released in June, in which it declined to give concrete guidelines for what businesses can and cannot say. The bureau instead said that “the act allows businesses to make whatever environmental claims they wish, as long as those claims are not false or misleading, and as long as those claims are adequately and properly tested or substantiated where required.”
But businesses still had concerns, and Carney ultimately rolled back the regulations. But that action too has raised flags. The new changes will create even more uncertainty and will constrain companies with additional legal risks by removing the internationally recognized methodology and not replacing it with anything else, KPMG Law LLP partner Conor Chell writes in The Globe and Mail.
Tooze similarly told The Mix that the new rules are too broad, and they take out too much without setting “guardrails” about how companies should substantiate their representations of products and actions. In particular, the rules should include specific wording to require methodology that is “robust” and “science-based”, she said. And the Competition Bureau still hasn’t cleared up exactly what statements are covered by the law, particularly those issued to investors.
Tooze said it’s too soon to tell whether the changes will make it easier for companies to greenwash their products, as much will depend on the Competition Bureau’s guidelines. Claims will still have to be substantiated, but the lack of parameters and guidelines means consumers and investors will no longer have any way to assess them.
“Thus, they are less likely to know if greenwashing is occurring,” said Tooze.













Impressive! Thanks for sharing this.