A new wave of legal action may already be taking shape after last week’s landmark advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on countries’ duty to tackle climate change. And one analyst says the decision will put Prime Minister Mark Carney in a tough spot.
In what one observer called “a day for the history books,” the United Nations’ top court said countries could be in violation of international law if they fail to take measures to protect the planet from climate change—and nations harmed by its effects could be entitled to reparations. The non-binding opinion, backed unanimously by the court’s 15 judges, was hailed as a turning point in international climate law.
“Failure of a state to take appropriate action to protect the climate system… may constitute an internationally wrongful act,” said ICJ President Yūji Iwasawa. He called the climate crisis “an existential problem of planetary proportions that imperils all forms of life and the very health of our planet.”
Within hours, legal analysts had begun laying out the new pathways the court had opened up for legal action—pushing countries to speed up their response to the climate emergency, and taking aim at the fossil fuel production that is throwing fuel on the fire.
Ralph Regenvanu, Vanuatu’s minister for climate change, said the opinion could give Pacific island nations “much greater leverage” in international climate negotiations, and in responding to climate pollution in its own region from major emitters like Australia. Under the advisory opinion, Australia “is committing internationally wrongful acts as it is sponsoring and subsidizing fossil fuel production and excessive emissions,” he declared.
“Australia is one of the major contributors to fossil fuel production. It’s the third-largest exporter of fossil fuels in the world. It’s a major contributor to emissions,” Regenvanu added. “It needs to align itself with the advisory opinion and cease this conduct that is contributing to emissions and start making reparations.”
Caribbean nations struck a similar note, with the prime minister of St. Vincent and the Grenadines declaring an “historic legal victory” in a case that “could see states ordered to pay reparations if they fail to tackle fossil fuels and prevent harm to the climate system,” the Guardian reports.
“What is very interesting is that it says that the obligations laid out in the important [climate change] treaties are not simply procedural,” Ralph Gonsalves told the UK-based paper. “They create substantive legal obligations.”
Bahamas Attorney General Ryan Pinder agreed that the ICJ’s “very strong position” would enable countries to “speak and argue about the adverse effects of the climate crisis on its people,” while helping them “go into other areas of the United Nations and other multilateral institutions that are human rights-focused.”
Axios says the ICJ “practically invites litigation over fossil fuels,” with its finding that “failure of a State to take appropriate action to protect the climate system from GHG emissions—including through fossil fuel production, fossil fuel consumption, the granting of fossil fuel exploration licences, or the provision of fossil fuel subsidies—may constitute an internationally wrongful act which is attributable to that State.”
All of this activity “creates stark choices” in Canada, writes Michael Byers, a professor of global politics and international law at the University of British Columbia, in a Globe and Mail opinion piece that cites the same paragraph from the more than 130-page decision. While ICJ opinions aren’t legally binding in themselves, he explains, other courts will rely on this one as a “highly authoritative statement” on the law.
“For the Canadian government, that means eliminating supports for the oil and gas industry now, or risking having to pay hundreds of billions of dollars in compensation to developing countries later,” Byers says. “For Canadian oil and gas companies, it means that a wave of climate damage cases could soon be headed their way, in domestic courts in Canada and around the world.”
Those “now-clear risks”, he adds, “have changed the parameters of viable public and corporate policy overnight.” And that means Carney “can no longer justify including fossil fuel projects among his infrastructure goals. This includes liquefied natural gas plants, the Northern Gateway oil pipeline to the Pacific coast, and carbon sequestration projects (which most climate experts agree are industry greenwashing). Indeed, the responsible thing to do after this advisory opinion would be for all subsidies for the oil and gas sector to be phased out, including industry-specific tax breaks.”
Byers says some “skeptics” might be inclined to just ignore the judgement. “But Canada, as a medium-sized country in a highly interdependent world, relies on international law in every domain—from enabling trade, foreign investment, banking, and transportation, to fighting drug trafficking, terrorism, tax evasion, and corruption, to cooperating with NATO allies under a collective security guarantee,” he writes. “You cannot pick and choose between different parts of the international legal system.”
And ignoring the ruling wouldn’t stop the flood of cases in domestic courts, the execution of judgements against fossil industry assets, or make climate change itself go away.
“For decades, Canada has been a free rider, benefitting from the efforts of others to transition away from fossil fuels while doing little ourselves,” Byers adds. Now, he says Carney “is uniquely positioned to educate the public about the climate crisis—and the hard choices and big changes it requires.”
Carbon Brief has an excellent, detailed explainer on the ICJ’s advisory opinion.












