A Canadian non-profit is mounting a last-ditch effort urging Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and the state environment and energy department to deny permits for a tunnel to extend the life of the Line 5 pipeline under the Great Lakes.
Line 5 has faced years of legal challenges and community opposition, with Calgary-based Enbridge Inc. claiming it can operate the line safely, but independent analysis concluding the pipeline is neither necessary nor safe.
“The Great Lakes provide drinking water for 40 million people. This means 40 million people binationally depend on the integrity of the Great Lakes to access their human rights to water,” Water Watchers writes, in a sign-on directed at Whitmer and the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE).
The 73-year-old pipeline, now 23 years past its designated lifespan, “is in critical condition and can be safely decommissioned without interrupting energy flows,” the letter adds, and it’s “a bad investment for people and planet during a critical time for climate action and energy transition. Construction itself would destroy wetlands, disrupt aquatic habitats, and expose the Great Lakes to further pollution, as well as drastically increased risks for oil and gas spills.”
Water Watchers says Indigenous communities in both Canada and the U.S. have called for Line 5’s removal, “not from ideology, but from lived entanglement with the Lakes.” It calls on Michigan to either set a higher environmental review standard for the tunnel or deny the permits outright.
The appeal to state officials follows Donald Trump’s moves to declare a national energy emergency on his first day back in office and direct the Army Corps of Engineers to use emergency permitting for energy and other projects, Grist and Interlochen Public Radio reported in May. At the time, David Bookbinder, director of law and policy at the nonprofit Environmental Integrity Project, said faster permitting would likely trigger lawsuits for higher-profile projects, but allow less prominent ones to fly under the radar.
At the time, the Army Corps said it would speed up its review of the Line 5 tunnel. Shane McCoy, a regulatory branch chief with the corps’ Detroit District, told reporters the emergency procedures “truncated” its timeline but that they weren’t “eliminating any of the steps” in the process.
The corps said the project qualified as an emergency and that a faster review will allow it “to address an energy supply situation” which would risk life, property, and unexpected and significant economic hardship. But seven tribal nations in Michigan that ultimately withdrew from the review warned that the process was deeply flawed, even before it was fast-tracked.
“The Straits of Mackinac is spiritually, culturally, and economically vital to tribal nations,” tribal leaders wrote in a letter to the corps, saying the agency’s environmental review process “disregards this deep place-based connection and instead seems designed to ensure that oil—and its associated threats—will continue to exist throughout the treaty ceded territory, including in the Great Lakes and the Straits.”
The decision to speed up that review was the “final straw,” added Whitney Gravelle, president of the Bay Mills Indian Community.
“We will continue to defend the rights of the Great Lakes,” she said in an emailed statement after the change was announced. “See you in court.”
As far back as February 2022, independent analysis indicated there were viable, cost-effective ways to ship oil and gas through Michigan, Ontario, and Quebec without relying on Line 5. “Enbridge continues to insist that the safest way to move oil is through pipelines,” wrote Environmental Defence Canada, in its overview of a research report authored by Martin Meyers of Meyers Energy Consulting, LLC, a firm whose past clients include Shell, Irving Oil, and fossil consultancy behemoth, Cambridge Research Energy Associates. “This could not be further from the truth.”












