A glimmer of hope on a “planned and just transition to end fossil fuels” wasn’t enough to salvage 10 days of international climate negotiations that ended with key participants warning that talks were moving too slowly to have any significant impact on a cascading climate emergency.
But it was still the most tangible outcome of a set of mid-year discussions that began with a haggle over the agenda for a meeting that was supposed to advance the fossil fuel phasedown and rapid adoption of renewable energy and energy efficiency to which countries agreed at the COP28 climate summit in Dubai in 2023.
The mid-year negotiations each year in Bonn, headquarters of the UN climate secretariat, aren’t meant to produce diplomatic breakthroughs: they’re smaller meetings, aimed at ironing out any technicalities they can before the larger COP convenes in the fall. But this year’s spring session produced progress on a Just Transition Work Programme (JTWP) that had stalled out during petrostate-dominated talks in Baku, Azerbaijan last year, where Saudi Arabia also successfully blocked references to fossil fuels and decisions on how to follow up on the Dubai declarations.
Now, governments “will submit an informal note to COP30 in Belém to frame discussions there,” Climate Home News reports. “It says the green transition should be fair to workers and protect nature, as well as advancing clean energy access and clean cooking for all. A just transition should also promote gender rights and human rights, particularly for Indigenous, disabled, migrant, and young people, the text says.”
Brazilian Environment Minister Marina Silva, who will host this year’s negotiations, said this year’s COP could deliver a clear roadmap for what a just transition would look like. “Perhaps we can come out of COP30 with a mandated group that can trace the roadmap for this transition,” she told media during a news conference at London Climate Action Week, which overlapped the last few days of the Bonn negotiations.
“It is the first time a senior minister has advocated for the plan to be discussed at COP30,” Climate Home writes.
The just transition discussion is central to the COP negotiations, Climate Action Network-International (CAN-I)’s Anabella Rosemberg told Climate Home, since governments “use their citizens as a barrier to action” when climate measures that don’t factor in social and economic justice end up raising costs and threatening jobs for regular citizens. Now, “that penny may be dropping,” Climate Home wrote Thursday.
But by the time those statements were issued, many of the major influencers in the COP negotiations had left Bonn to attend sessions in London, leaving observers and some negotiating blocs to warn that the process was moving far too slowly.
World Wildlife Fund welcomed the progress on the just transition text, but warned that negotiators had “struggled to agree on key points” like climate change adaptation, climate finance, and implementation of COP28 commitments on energy and nature.
“In Bonn, we needed to see developed countries step up and put much-needed momentum into international climate talks,” said WWF Global Climate and Energy Policy Lead Fernanda de Carvalho. “But progress in key areas like the transition away from fossil fuels and ending deforestation did not materialize.”
The Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) said it was “bewildered by the backward tracking on finance,” while the Least Developed Countries (LDC) bloc called for a tripling of adaptation finance from 2022 levels by 2030.
“We are falling further and further behind, and if countries do not act with real ambition to achieve the pledges they made when we all committed to the Paris Agreement 10 years ago, we will be truly lost,” AOSIS and LDC told media covering the negotiations. “Climate change and its devastating impacts are accelerating, why are we not acting at least at an equal pace?”
Despite the progress on just transition, Climate Action Network said the Bonn negotiations “laid bare a system in crisis.”
“Even as NATO leaders just 200 kilometres away pledged more than US$1 trillion a year in additional military spending, rich polluting countries showed up at the climate talks pleading poverty. The silence on war, genocide, and rising global inequality was deafening,” CAN said in a release.
“Despite the escalating toll of climate impacts and injustice, these talks revealed a growing chasm between the urgent demands of communities on the front lines of climate breakdown and the hollow, evasive language of a process struggling to retain relevance.”
[Disclosure: Energy Mix Productions is a member of Climate Action Network-Canada, CAN International’s Canadian node.]
The glacial pace of the COP process had more than 200 climate campaign groups calling for reform of UN negotiations that have “reached breaking point”, Climate Home reports, while decrying a “trade show” atmosphere at a series of annual COP summits that bring together tens of thousands of delegates produce few if any real-world results. The groups called on the UN climate secretariat to abandon a consensus process that allows petrostates to block consensus on meaningful climate action and replace it with the kind of voting rules that already apply to many other UN conventions.
“For 30 years, the climate negotiations have systematically failed to deliver climate justice, undermined international law, and allowed the fossil fuel industry to write the rules,” said Lien Vandamme, senior campaigner with the Center for International Environmental Law. “The absence of agreed procedures for decision-making allows big polluting countries to hold the negotiations hostage.”









