The Energy Mix
Subscribe
Donate
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Energy Mix
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
Subscribe
Donate
The Energy Mix
Subscribe

High-Speed Rail’s Time Has Finally Come. But Free Transit is a Better Investment.

August 25, 2025
Reading time: 6 minutes
Full Story: Pivot Strategic
Author: Aaron Freeman

pxhere

pxhere

Many advocates of high-speed rail (HSR) feel their time has finally come with Prime Minister Mark Carney’s prioritization of “major projects” that have provincial or territorial support. Like those governments, I’m reluctant to say no to a massive cheque for a clean transportation project in Canada’s busiest transportation corridor between Toronto and Quebec City.

Most environmentalists have long supported the endeavour, since trains are much cleaner than fossil-fuelled air or road travel.

I personally travel from Toronto to Ottawa a dozen times a year, and while I take the train when I can make it work, departure schedules and work demands mean that I generally have to stay an extra night away from my family, so I fly more often than an environmentalist should.

I prefer the train, and if a high-speed option existed, I would take it based on the options that are available to me today. But we’re not building HSR for today.

It will take at least 15 years to build it, and likely much longer, despite the prime minister’s desire to build stuff faster. (Just ask our friends in California.) In that time, the Quebec and Ontario grids, which are already more than 90% emissions-free, will be very close to 100%.

More on the GHGs in a minute. First, the bigger issue with HSR.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

The general assumption around high-speed rail is that the main competition will be with air travel. Taking into account commutes and wait times, door-to-door HSR will take about four hours from Toronto to Ottawa, about an hour more than air travel. The cost would be comparable to air travel, unless taxpayers massively subsidized operating expenses.

The GHG benefits would be significant over air travel, although many now argue that electric and biofuel options for air travel will be fully deployed for commuter air travel in corridors like Toronto-Quebec City over the next decade. Rail would still be cleaner, but not to the same extent as today.

But there’s a third option to air and HSR, and it will out-compete in terms of convenience, price, and in the end, even GHG reduction: A fully electric, self-driving car, powered by a net-zero grid, that picks me up and drops me off exactly where and when I need it to, for a third of the ticket cost.

The assumption is that we can seduce people away from polluting airplanes if they have a convenient alternative. But for those who are motivated by convenience (i.e., virtually all air travellers), will it really be a more pleasant option to get in your self-driving Uber from home, get out at the train station, wait for your train on someone else’s schedule, then get off at your destination just to get in another Uber to get to your final destination? Doesn’t that sound a little too much like what you’re doing when you fly?

From a convenience standpoint, why not just get in the self-driving car exactly when you damn well feel like it, set up your laptop, and arrive exactly where you need to be in one shot?

I know I haven’t won you over on the environmental benefits, but stay with me. Increasing car traffic undoubtedly creates new highway demand and sprawl. But there’s also a foregone opportunity associated with the $80- to $100-billion price tag of high speed rail—money that could do a lot of other things with environmental and social benefit—including the one thing that has the greatest potential to reduce traffic and sprawl.

By far the largest-ever federal investment in public transit was made over the past decade—$30 billion, recently renewed for the next decade for another $30 billion. What if we took that next tranche of $30 billion and doubled it? If you included operating costs within this investment, as most federal European national governments do in their transit funding, you’d address one of the biggest weaknesses in our transit systems, while immediately winning over mayors across the country.

If that sounds like a pretty good deal, you’ll love what I’m proposing next. Because for what HSR will cost, even after doubling that transit investment over the next decade, we would still have enough to also make transit free in every community that has a transit system across Canada. (See my basis for calculating this below.)

Unlike the far-off and highly speculative prospects of HSR, the transit option would immediately create a massive constituency that benefits from it right away, not 15 to 20 years from now. Unlike HSR’s small constituency of wealthy commuters, free and efficient transit nation-wide would eliminate the cost of getting to work and school—and in many cases the need for a car—for millions of everyday Canadians, especially those struggling to get out of poverty. Making transit a viable, comfortable, and free alternative to the daily car commute would also do far more than HSR to limit sprawl and the need for highway investment.

Geographically, it would benefit every large and most small- to mid-sized communities across Canada, not just a dozen communities concentrated in central Canada. The broader economic spin-offs of shorter commute times alone would be massive. (Just ask the Toronto Board of Trade.)

From a GHG cost-per-tonne standpoint, there’s no contest. The proponent estimates HSR can shave 39 megatonnes of emissions. That almost certainly overestimates the number of people who would take rail, as well as the GHG impact of the alternatives that will be much cleaner by the time HSR is operational. But even if the estimate is correct, at a likely price tag of $100 billion, the GHG reduction would cost $5,000 per tonne.  There is literally no serious GHG reduction policy that has a cost that high. Oil and gas methane reduction costs about $11 per tonne; building retrofits range from negative cost to about $50 per tonne; and carbon direct air capture schemes are as low as $100 per tonne, to take a few examples. Public transit is not the best value from a strict GHG reduction standpoint, but it is still an order of magnitude less expensive than HSR.

Still, high-speed rail has a romantic, European feel to it. We want to want it. Some enviros will argue that we should both do HSR and get serious about public transit.

But as we pause on the eve of fiscal austerity the likes of which we haven’t seen in a generation, we’re going to have to make choices. And on my math, there are better alternatives to HSR.

This post first appeared in the new newsletter just launched by Aaron Freeman, Managing Partner at Pivot Strategic. Republished by permission.

Aaron Freeman

Energy Mix Guest Writer







in Canada, Cities & Communities, Finance & Investment, Leisure & Recreation, Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion, Shipping & Aviation, Transit

Trending Stories

More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)
Drought & Wildfires

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.3k
(File photo by Fibonacci Blue/flickr)
Climate Action

Climate Voices See Complications With Blocking New Oil and Gas

November 10, 2026
572
PixTreats/pixabay
International Agencies & Studies

IEA Sees Renewables Surging World-Wide as Countries Seek Energy Security, Lower Costs

November 12, 2026
629

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

High-Speed Rail’s Time Has Finally Come. But Free Transit is a Better Investment.

August 25, 2025
Reading time: 6 minutes
Full Story: Pivot Strategic
Author: Aaron Freeman

pxhere

pxhere

Many advocates of high-speed rail (HSR) feel their time has finally come with Prime Minister Mark Carney’s prioritization of “major projects” that have provincial or territorial support. Like those governments, I’m reluctant to say no to a massive cheque for a clean transportation project in Canada’s busiest transportation corridor between Toronto and Quebec City.

Most environmentalists have long supported the endeavour, since trains are much cleaner than fossil-fuelled air or road travel.

I personally travel from Toronto to Ottawa a dozen times a year, and while I take the train when I can make it work, departure schedules and work demands mean that I generally have to stay an extra night away from my family, so I fly more often than an environmentalist should.

I prefer the train, and if a high-speed option existed, I would take it based on the options that are available to me today. But we’re not building HSR for today.

It will take at least 15 years to build it, and likely much longer, despite the prime minister’s desire to build stuff faster. (Just ask our friends in California.) In that time, the Quebec and Ontario grids, which are already more than 90% emissions-free, will be very close to 100%.

More on the GHGs in a minute. First, the bigger issue with HSR.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

The general assumption around high-speed rail is that the main competition will be with air travel. Taking into account commutes and wait times, door-to-door HSR will take about four hours from Toronto to Ottawa, about an hour more than air travel. The cost would be comparable to air travel, unless taxpayers massively subsidized operating expenses.

The GHG benefits would be significant over air travel, although many now argue that electric and biofuel options for air travel will be fully deployed for commuter air travel in corridors like Toronto-Quebec City over the next decade. Rail would still be cleaner, but not to the same extent as today.

But there’s a third option to air and HSR, and it will out-compete in terms of convenience, price, and in the end, even GHG reduction: A fully electric, self-driving car, powered by a net-zero grid, that picks me up and drops me off exactly where and when I need it to, for a third of the ticket cost.

The assumption is that we can seduce people away from polluting airplanes if they have a convenient alternative. But for those who are motivated by convenience (i.e., virtually all air travellers), will it really be a more pleasant option to get in your self-driving Uber from home, get out at the train station, wait for your train on someone else’s schedule, then get off at your destination just to get in another Uber to get to your final destination? Doesn’t that sound a little too much like what you’re doing when you fly?

From a convenience standpoint, why not just get in the self-driving car exactly when you damn well feel like it, set up your laptop, and arrive exactly where you need to be in one shot?

I know I haven’t won you over on the environmental benefits, but stay with me. Increasing car traffic undoubtedly creates new highway demand and sprawl. But there’s also a foregone opportunity associated with the $80- to $100-billion price tag of high speed rail—money that could do a lot of other things with environmental and social benefit—including the one thing that has the greatest potential to reduce traffic and sprawl.

By far the largest-ever federal investment in public transit was made over the past decade—$30 billion, recently renewed for the next decade for another $30 billion. What if we took that next tranche of $30 billion and doubled it? If you included operating costs within this investment, as most federal European national governments do in their transit funding, you’d address one of the biggest weaknesses in our transit systems, while immediately winning over mayors across the country.

If that sounds like a pretty good deal, you’ll love what I’m proposing next. Because for what HSR will cost, even after doubling that transit investment over the next decade, we would still have enough to also make transit free in every community that has a transit system across Canada. (See my basis for calculating this below.)

Unlike the far-off and highly speculative prospects of HSR, the transit option would immediately create a massive constituency that benefits from it right away, not 15 to 20 years from now. Unlike HSR’s small constituency of wealthy commuters, free and efficient transit nation-wide would eliminate the cost of getting to work and school—and in many cases the need for a car—for millions of everyday Canadians, especially those struggling to get out of poverty. Making transit a viable, comfortable, and free alternative to the daily car commute would also do far more than HSR to limit sprawl and the need for highway investment.

Geographically, it would benefit every large and most small- to mid-sized communities across Canada, not just a dozen communities concentrated in central Canada. The broader economic spin-offs of shorter commute times alone would be massive. (Just ask the Toronto Board of Trade.)

From a GHG cost-per-tonne standpoint, there’s no contest. The proponent estimates HSR can shave 39 megatonnes of emissions. That almost certainly overestimates the number of people who would take rail, as well as the GHG impact of the alternatives that will be much cleaner by the time HSR is operational. But even if the estimate is correct, at a likely price tag of $100 billion, the GHG reduction would cost $5,000 per tonne.  There is literally no serious GHG reduction policy that has a cost that high. Oil and gas methane reduction costs about $11 per tonne; building retrofits range from negative cost to about $50 per tonne; and carbon direct air capture schemes are as low as $100 per tonne, to take a few examples. Public transit is not the best value from a strict GHG reduction standpoint, but it is still an order of magnitude less expensive than HSR.

Still, high-speed rail has a romantic, European feel to it. We want to want it. Some enviros will argue that we should both do HSR and get serious about public transit.

But as we pause on the eve of fiscal austerity the likes of which we haven’t seen in a generation, we’re going to have to make choices. And on my math, there are better alternatives to HSR.

This post first appeared in the new newsletter just launched by Aaron Freeman, Managing Partner at Pivot Strategic. Republished by permission.

Aaron Freeman

Energy Mix Guest Writer







in Canada, Cities & Communities, Finance & Investment, Leisure & Recreation, Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion, Shipping & Aviation, Transit

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Trending Stories

More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.3k
(File photo by Fibonacci Blue/flickr)

Climate Voices See Complications With Blocking New Oil and Gas

November 10, 2026
572
PixTreats/pixabay

IEA Sees Renewables Surging World-Wide as Countries Seek Energy Security, Lower Costs

November 12, 2026
629

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

Copyright 2026 © Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy and Copyright
  • Cookie Policy
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.