ExxonMobil CEO Darren Woods’ comments during an interview—where he depicted the oil and gas major as a well-meaning company whose hands are tied to address a consumer-driven climate crisis—have drawn criticism from climate advocates who accuse him of “gaslighting” the public.
“It’s like a drug lord blaming everyone but himself for drug problems,” Gernot Wagner, a climate economist at Columbia Business School, told the Guardian after Woods’ interview with Fortune, in which he said citizens—not fossil companies like Exxon that have poured billions of dollars into product promotion and climate denial—are responsible for climate change. “I hate to tell you, but you’re the chief executive of the largest publicly-traded oil company, you have influence, you make decisions that matter.”
“Exxon is at the mercy of markets but they are also shaping them, they are shaping policy,” Wagner added. “So no, you can’t blame the public for the failure to fix climate change.”
The interview in late February started with what environmental activist Bill McKibben called “one of the classic softball questions of all time,” when Fortune editor Alan Murray put to Woods that a multinational oil giant like Exxon—which makes billions of dollars for the company and millions for its CEO from selling fossil fuels—“can’t possibly be serious about addressing climate change,” asking him to explain why that notion is wrong.
Woods responded that Exxon is essentially a technology company that focuses on meeting people’s needs by “transforming molecules”—in this case, carbon and hydrogen. Today, a large part of that technology goes into combusting those molecules, Woods said, and Exxon sees its job as using those capabilities to address the needs of society. While acknowledging that technologies like wind, solar, and electric vehicles have an important part to play in decarbonizing energy, he said he doesn’t see that as a space where Exxon’s capabilities can be brought to bear.
Later in the interview, he said Exxon’s decarbonization activities cannot be compared to other stakeholders’ investments in renewables. That’s because Exxon, by focusing on decarbonizing fuels for hard-to-abate sectors, faces a different investment environment that involves building companies from scratch—as opposed to investing in the relatively more established markets for what he called “electron solutions.”
“We don’t see the ability to generate above-average returns for investors” from those solutions, Woods said. “We recognize a need for that. We just don’t see that as an appropriate use of ExxonMobil’s capabilities.”
Such statements reveal the pernicious role of fossil fuel profitability in hampering the energy transition, McKibben wrote in his newsletter, The Crucial Years.
“The sun and the wind deliver the energy for free, and all you need is some equipment to turn it into electrons,” McKibben explained. “But Exxon controls the molecules—that’s what oil and gas reserves are.”
“And that control means they can make outsize profits—as long as they can persuade the world to keep burning stuff.”
Woods sees a continuing role for fossil fuels in the energy transition—and in generating profit for Exxon. During the interview, he addressed the demands of activist shareholders who he sees as “micromanaging” Exxon’s business to stop the production of oil and gas.
“That’s contrary to the benefit of most of our shareholders,” he told Murray. In response, Exxon is taking its own in-house activists to court to protect the company, which he said is also in the best interests of shareholders.
“And, by the way, the best interests of society,” interviewer Murray tacked on, in agreement with Woods. “I mean, stopping the sale of oil and gas is not going to be good for the world at this point in history.”
[Murray and Woods’ sweet moment of solidarity defies the consensus among doctors, economists, and scientists from varied fields who find that putting an end to the sale of oil and gas is urgently needed to halt the devastating impacts of greenhouse gas emissions.—Ed.]
When asked about Exxon’s role in spreading disinformation that held back climate action, Woods dismissed those actions as a thing of the past, having happened 30 years ago. But journalists and campaigners say the company’s active support for climate denial has been ongoing for much longer, and that Exxon has continued to push back against calls to curtail oil and gas use.
Woods maintained the world has moved on, adding that Exxon is now looking to determine: “How can we contribute to a solution set, not debate the past?”
When it comes down to it, he said, the current state of technology and policies does not put the world on track to complete the energy transition by 2050. He blamed that on governments and the public for acting too slowly—despite Exxon’s well-established campaign to undermine climate science over several decades.
“We’ve waited too long to open the aperture on the solution sets in terms of what we need as a society,” Woods said, a comment that unleashed widespread criticism.
“For decades, they told us that the science was too uncertain to justify action, that it was premature to act, and that we could and should wait and see how things developed,” said Naomi Oreskes, a Harvard science historian and co-author of a 2021 paper about Exxon’s climate denialism.
“Now the CEO says: ‘oh dear, we’ve waited too long’,” she added. “If this isn’t gaslighting, I don’t know what is.”












