The world has far fewer places to securely store carbon dioxide deep underground than previously thought, steeply lowering its potential to help stem global warming, according to a new study that challenges long-held industry claims about the practice.
The study, published Wednesday in the journal Nature, found that global carbon storage capacity was 10 times less than previous estimates after ruling out geological formations where the gas could leak, trigger earthquakes or contaminate groundwater, or had other limitations, The Associated Press reports. That means carbon capture and storage would only have the potential to reduce human-caused warming by 0.7°C—far less than previous claims of around 5-6°C, researchers said.
“Carbon storage is often portrayed as a way out of the climate crisis. Our findings make clear that it is a limited tool” and reaffirm “the extreme importance of reducing emissions as fast and as soon as possible,” said lead author Matthew Gidden, a research professor at the University Maryland’s Center for Global Sustainability. The study was led by the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, where Gidden also is a senior researcher in the energy, climate and environment program.
The study is the latest knock on a technology, for years promoted by oil and gas industry, that has often been touted as a climate solution. Today, carbon capture is far from being deployed at scale, despite billions of dollars in investments and lavish government subsidies around the world, and the amount of carbon currently captured is just a tiny fraction of the billions of tonnes of carbon dioxide emitted every year.
The 2015 Paris climate agreement called for limiting average global temperature increase to 2°C, but ideally below 1.5°C (2.7F), compared to pre-industrial levels in the early 1800s.
Many scenarios for hitting that target have relied on carbon removal and storage, assuming the potential was “very large” because previous estimates didn’t account for vulnerable areas that might not be suitable, said study co-author Alexandre Koberle, a researcher at the University of Lisbon.
“That was never systematically challenged and tested,” said Koberle, adding that the study was the first to examine which areas should be avoided, leading to what the authors call a “prudent potential” that minimizes risks to people and the environment.
The study doesn’t conclude that carbon capture and storage isn’t important to keep global temperatures in check. But researchers said countries must prioritize how they use the limited storage space available and do so in conjunction with fast and deep emissions reductions.
The technology should be used for sectors that are difficult to decarbonize, such as cement production, aviation, and agriculture, and not to extend the life of polluting power plants or prolong the use of oil and gas, Koberle said.
Industry officials defended carbon capture and storage as having an inherently low risk and say emerging technologies, such as storing carbon dioxide in basalt formations where it becomes mineralized, could dramatically increase total storage volumes.
What’s more, its use is “not optional if we hope to address global warming,” said Jessie Stolark, executive director of the Carbon Capture Coalition, adding that it must be combined with other ways to reduce emissions and balanced with the need for reliable and affordable energy. [It isn’t clear from the AP coverage whether the Coalition understands that the most affordable sources of energy across most of the world, solar+storage and wind+storage, require no carbon capture because their operations emit no climate pollution—Ed.]
Rob Jackson, head of the Global Carbon Project, a group of scientists who monitor greenhouse gas emissions, praised the study for its cautionary perspective. Though he’s optimistic that carbon capture technology itself will work, he believes very little will ever be stored “because I don’t think we’re willing to pay for it.”
“If we aren’t willing to cut emissions today, why do we expect that people in the future will just automatically pay to remove our pollution?” Jackson said. “We’re just continuing to pollute and not addressing the root of the problem.”
The most commonly used carbon capture technology allows facilities to capture and store around 60% of their carbon dioxide emissions during the production process, AP writes. Anything above that rate is much more difficult and expensive, according to the International Energy Agency, although that hasn’t stopped some Canadian projects from claiming much better results.
Gidden, the lead author, said it’s clear that scaling up carbon storage will be important to bring emissions to net-zero and to eventually reduce them, and agreed the use of basalt formations is promising. But the world can’t afford to wait for that to happen before acting decisively to slash fossil fuel emissions.
“If we prolong our dependence on fossil fuels for too long with the expectation that we will offset that by simply storing carbon underground, we’re likely saddling future generations with a nearly impossible task of dealing with not only our mess, but limited ways of cleaning it up,” he said.
The Canadian Press republished this Associated Press story on Sept. 3, 2025.














Why is it that we are never told the total and true costs of what it takes to put up a wind farm or a solar farm. The components needed just don’t show up on site, and away it goes. There is a lot of mining required somewhere to produce the solar panels. They are not produced or made in America. The same goes for the components to produce the wind generators and the blades needed. Then all these components have to be loaded on ocean ships and transported to a dock where it then gets placed on special highway trailers, and with police escorts and pilot cars, the components make their way to the site locations. The footings for the solar are not a big deal, but the wind machines have how much rebar and concrete put into the ground to ensure they can’t blow over. My guess is there is more concrete placed on a solar farm project than at any power plant site. Power plants have costs associated with their construction too. Lets do a fair comparison of all these costs, and their yearly performance and maintenance costs, and expected life cycle. Wind and solar can’t produce 24/7 so they need backup. What are those costs?
A power plant has expenses. They have 24 hour engineers on staff ensuring the power plant is producing exactly what is required at that time. It has to calculate with yearly maintenance. Please line all the numbers up. Do not say solar and wind give free electricity, because we know that is an untruth. Please tell us the people, What is the truth.
Well, just briefly — are you suggesting that those supply chain costs don’t apply to fossil projects? And it isn’t just in the construction phase. It turns out that some large part of the volume of international shipping, an industry that has steadfastly refused to meaningfully bring down its climate and other pollution, is devoted to burning fossil fuels to transport fossil fuels across oceans. I don’t have the number right at hand, but I think it’s in the range of 1/4 to 1/3. (Readers, please, fill this one in if you’ve got it!)
By contrast, no, actually — nothing is free of impacts, but the energy and material inputs are less for solar, wind, and batteries. Once those installations are built, of course they need monitoring and maintenance, but both the cost and the environmental and community impacts are tiny compared to fossil plants.
I really appreciate the point — one that I learned from a front-line community that is badly in need of a more diversified economy — is that the local job creation doesn’t come from a solar farm once it’s built. It’s that the availability of clean, reliable power at 6¢ per kilowatt-hour is an excellent draw for advanced manufacturing and other new businesses — across all sectors, not just renewable energy manufacturers — for whom energy is the first question when they’re doing site selection.