The Energy Mix
Subscribe
Donate
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Energy Mix
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact
Subscribe
Donate
The Energy Mix
Subscribe

Analysts Warn of ‘Wishful Thinking’ on Carbon Pricing, CCS

May 1, 2016
Reading time: 3 minutes

Mark Dixon/flickr

Mark Dixon/flickr

Mark Dixon/flickr
Mark Dixon/flickr

It’s time for climate strategies that replace wishful thinking with a clearer emphasis on policies and technologies that can deliver deep greenhouse gas reductions, according to two analyses published over the last week.

In Canada, even supporters of carbon pricing warn that economic levers can’t replace regulation as a climate policy tool. And in The Guardian, three leading climate analysts point to the “hype” in international climate models that presume widespread deployment carbon capture technologies that don’t yet exist.

In Canada, DeSmog reports, the Trudeau government has made carbon pricing such a high priority that the First Ministers’ meeting in early March nearly broke down over the question of a national minimum price. “The carbon pricing lobby sucked all the air out of the room,” said energy economist Mark Jaccard, drawing attention away from a wider toolbox of options.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

“You can meet our Paris Agreement targets strictly with emissions pricing, whether cap and trade or a carbon tax,” he said. “You can also do it strictly with regulations.” But DeSmog notes that Jaccard’s research team at Simon Fraser University has “put together a rather convincing case showing regulations are responsible for cutting more GHG emissions than carbon pricing systems in Canada and elsewhere in the world.”

Jaccard said the British Columbia government’s electricity regulations eliminated more emissions than its much-celebrated carbon tax, while Ontario’s move to phase out coal-fired generation still stands as North America’s “single largest regulatory action” to cut carbon, the equivalent of taking seven million cars off the road.

“Is a carbon price more economically efficient? Of course it is,” Jaccard told DeSmog. “All I am saying is can’t we—we so-called experts like me—learn a little bit from evidence from around the world, from what’s gone on in Canada? And that’s the reason I might talk about regulations.”

In The Guardian, meanwhile, analysts Tim Kruger, Oliver Geden, and Steve Rayner contend that the economic models behind international climate policy are built on an unhealthy dose of wishful thinking. “Technologies that remove carbon dioxide from the air are assumed in the models that avoid dangerous climate change,” the paper notes. “But such technologies do not yet exist, and it is unclear whether they could be deployed at meaningful scale.”

Most of the modelling that points toward a 2.0°C limit on average global warming—and all of the modelling for a 1.5°C scenario—presumes massive deployment of biomass energy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS). That approach has been written off as “science fiction” by at least one UK advocacy group involved in discussion at the Paris conference. Kruger, Geden, and Rayner note that “while the constituent steps of this process have been demonstrated, there are but a few, small examples of the combined process. To rely on this technique to deliver us from climate change is to demonstrate a degree of faith that is out of keeping with scientific rigour.”

The analysts raise serious questions about BECCS’ technical and economic viability and its social acceptability. “Even with rapid decarbonization, there will be a need to achieve net negative emissions during the second half of this century,” they acknowledge, and “that objective cannot be achieved from a standing start.” But “to model what you want to happen, rather than what there is evidence could happen, is to lose the thread of reality. It is redolent of a defeated leader issuing orders to armies that have long since ceased to exist—not so much vision, as delusion.”







in Carbon Pricing

Trending Stories

Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne at 2025 Collision Conferencef/flickr
Finance & Investment

Federal Budget Funds Clean Grid and Energy Efficiency, Touts ‘Investment Supercycle’ Built on Major Projects

November 6, 2026
986
More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)
Drought & Wildfires

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.2k
Alberta Environment and Protected Areas Minister Grant Hunter, Alberta Newsroom/flickr
Legal & Regulatory

Alberta Accused of Rushing Environmental Law Changes Behind Closed Doors

November 5, 2026
979

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

Analysts Warn of ‘Wishful Thinking’ on Carbon Pricing, CCS

May 1, 2016
Reading time: 3 minutes

Mark Dixon/flickr

Mark Dixon/flickr

Mark Dixon/flickr
Mark Dixon/flickr

It’s time for climate strategies that replace wishful thinking with a clearer emphasis on policies and technologies that can deliver deep greenhouse gas reductions, according to two analyses published over the last week.

In Canada, even supporters of carbon pricing warn that economic levers can’t replace regulation as a climate policy tool. And in The Guardian, three leading climate analysts point to the “hype” in international climate models that presume widespread deployment carbon capture technologies that don’t yet exist.

In Canada, DeSmog reports, the Trudeau government has made carbon pricing such a high priority that the First Ministers’ meeting in early March nearly broke down over the question of a national minimum price. “The carbon pricing lobby sucked all the air out of the room,” said energy economist Mark Jaccard, drawing attention away from a wider toolbox of options.

Get the latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox.

Subscribe Today

View our latest digests

“You can meet our Paris Agreement targets strictly with emissions pricing, whether cap and trade or a carbon tax,” he said. “You can also do it strictly with regulations.” But DeSmog notes that Jaccard’s research team at Simon Fraser University has “put together a rather convincing case showing regulations are responsible for cutting more GHG emissions than carbon pricing systems in Canada and elsewhere in the world.”

Jaccard said the British Columbia government’s electricity regulations eliminated more emissions than its much-celebrated carbon tax, while Ontario’s move to phase out coal-fired generation still stands as North America’s “single largest regulatory action” to cut carbon, the equivalent of taking seven million cars off the road.

“Is a carbon price more economically efficient? Of course it is,” Jaccard told DeSmog. “All I am saying is can’t we—we so-called experts like me—learn a little bit from evidence from around the world, from what’s gone on in Canada? And that’s the reason I might talk about regulations.”

In The Guardian, meanwhile, analysts Tim Kruger, Oliver Geden, and Steve Rayner contend that the economic models behind international climate policy are built on an unhealthy dose of wishful thinking. “Technologies that remove carbon dioxide from the air are assumed in the models that avoid dangerous climate change,” the paper notes. “But such technologies do not yet exist, and it is unclear whether they could be deployed at meaningful scale.”

Most of the modelling that points toward a 2.0°C limit on average global warming—and all of the modelling for a 1.5°C scenario—presumes massive deployment of biomass energy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS). That approach has been written off as “science fiction” by at least one UK advocacy group involved in discussion at the Paris conference. Kruger, Geden, and Rayner note that “while the constituent steps of this process have been demonstrated, there are but a few, small examples of the combined process. To rely on this technique to deliver us from climate change is to demonstrate a degree of faith that is out of keeping with scientific rigour.”

The analysts raise serious questions about BECCS’ technical and economic viability and its social acceptability. “Even with rapid decarbonization, there will be a need to achieve net negative emissions during the second half of this century,” they acknowledge, and “that objective cannot be achieved from a standing start.” But “to model what you want to happen, rather than what there is evidence could happen, is to lose the thread of reality. It is redolent of a defeated leader issuing orders to armies that have long since ceased to exist—not so much vision, as delusion.”







in Carbon Pricing

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Trending Stories

Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne at 2025 Collision Conferencef/flickr

Federal Budget Funds Clean Grid and Energy Efficiency, Touts ‘Investment Supercycle’ Built on Major Projects

November 6, 2026
986
More than one-third of the Jasper townsite was destroyed by wildfire in 2024  (Laura Durno/Twitter)

Climate Change Made High Temperatures Twice as Likely Before Jasper Wildfire

August 22, 2024
2.2k
Alberta Environment and Protected Areas Minister Grant Hunter, Alberta Newsroom/flickr

Alberta Accused of Rushing Environmental Law Changes Behind Closed Doors

November 5, 2026
979

An ‘Extinction-Level Event’ for Trump. A Renewable Energy Surge. A Spiralling Climate Crisis. Is Your Head Spinning Yet?

by Mitchell Beer
November 8, 2026

…

Follow Us

Copyright 2026 © Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy and Copyright
  • Cookie Policy
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Buildings & Infrastructure
    • Climate Equity & Justice
      • Energy Poverty
      • Indigenous Rights & Reconciliation
    • Climate Finance
      • Community Climate Finance
      • Finance & Investment
      • Insurance & Liability
      • Subsidies
    • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
      • Biodiversity & Habitat
      • Drought & Wildfires
      • Forests & Deforestation
      • Health & Safety
      • Heat & Temperature
      • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
      • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Emissions
      • Carbon Levels & Measurement
      • CCS & Negative Emissions
      • Methane
    • Energy
      • Renewables
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear
      • Batteries & Storage
      • Energy Efficiency
      • Power Grids
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Industry
      • Data Centres & Tech
      • Critical Minerals & Mining
      • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Policy & Politics
      • Carbon Pricing
      • COP Conferences
      • Elections
      • Energy Politics
      • International Security & War
      • Legal & Regulatory
    • Research & Innovation
      • International Agencies & Studies
      • Research & Development
    • Society & Culture
      • Climate Action
      • Mis/Disinformation & Greenwashing
      • Jobs & Training
      • Leisure & Recreation
      • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Transportation & Mobility
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Shipping & Aviation
      • Transit
      • Walking, Biking & Micromobility
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • International
    • Mexico & the Caribbean
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Subnational
    • United States
    • UK & Europe
  • Special Coverage
    • The Weekender
    • IEA2026
    • Canada’s Major Projects Office
    • Hidden Wonder Valley
    • COP30
    • Cities & Communities
    • Heat & Power
    • Community Climate Finance
  • More Resources
  • About
  • Contact

Copyright 2025 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.