Alberta is rushing through changes to its primary environmental legislation with little transparency and inadequate consultation, warn First Nations, landowners, and environmental groups, after the province gave Albertans just nine days for feedback.
The Chiefs Steering Committee (CSC), a technical advisory group representing First Nations in Treaty 6, 7, and 8 across Alberta, told The Energy Mix they were not informed of changes coming to the Environmental Protection and Enhancement Act (EPEA) and that none of the seven chiefs who sit on the committee was invited to give input.
CSC member Piikani Nation Chief Troy Knowlton said in a statement that Alberta should stop the review and meet with chiefs before “rewriting environmental protections behind closed doors” concerning contaminated sites, land reclamation, water quality, and industrial approvals across Treaty territories.
Knowlton said the rushed comment window and “zero outreach to First Nations” were unacceptable. “Making changes to these regulations directly impacts our Treaty rights, our waters, and our traditional lands.”
The Alberta Wilderness Association (AWA) is calling on the government to expand the engagement process and allow more time for feedback on changes to the EPEA scheduled for the spring legislative session.
“The Alberta government states that public participation and transparency remain foundational to EPEA, however, providing just nine days to review and respond to proposed changes to the province’s primary environmental protection legislation falls short of meaningful engagement,” AWA Executive Director Debborah Donnelly said in a news release.
AWA says it received a discussion paper with “significant” EPEA amendments on October 20, stakeholder engagement was scheduled with the provincial government on October 21, and feedback was requested by October 30.
“The review places considerable emphasis on regulatory efficiency and the needs of industry, without a corresponding focus on strengthening environmental protections or maintaining ecological integrity,” AWA wrote.
The province said it is modernizing the legislation and five foundational regulations to “reduce red tape, improve approval timelines, and provide greater certainty.”
The discussion paper sent to the AWA shows [pdf] the government is looking at a wide range of changes, including writing rules on what information is shared with the public, who and how they can participate in the regulatory process, replacing approvals for some activities with a requirement for simple notification (“registration”), as well as recognizing designated zones and giving authority for special regulations in those zones.
Public interest scientist Dr. Bill Donahue, who formerly worked at Alberta Environment and Parks, told The Mix that Alberta is “probably going to be subjected to the worst and most significant declines in water supply due to climate change.” He said it’s the “biggest of the risks coming in Alberta’s future” and that it will “be made worse by whatever they’re doing in terms of the changes to the environmental protection act and regulations.”
Donahue said an engagement process shouldn’t be done behind closed doors and be this rushed, adding that he suspects industry has been involved since the beginning in rewriting the legislation and regulations. He called it a “farce” expecting the public to comment without information.
Neither the Minister of Environment and Protected Areas, Grant Hunter, nor Premier Danielle Smith has acknowledged multiple emails with questions from The Mix about who attendedinvitation-only meetings held in June, or a series of closed one-hour webinars in October. Written submissions from the public were open for less than 10 days, and no discussion paper was provided before closing on Oct. 30.
“A public process could be completely valid, but at the very least, if you’re going to have a review, then reveal what changes you’re considering, including the drafts of the legislation and the regulatory changes,” said Donahue.
“If a government can’t publicly defend its decisions and actions, then it’s probably making the wrong decisions and pursuing the wrong action,” he added.
The Alberta Surface Rights Federation, an advocacy group representing landowners across the province, said it was not invited to give input and is also asking to see the specifics in writing. President Bill Heidecker wrote to Smith on Oct. 30, calling on the government to publish the proposed statutory and regulatory text, including an assessment of how each change will affect landowner protections.
Heidecker told The Mix his organization found out about the consultation on social media, despite having repeatedly brought forward related concerns to the government through various means, most recently in a series of meetings with the Premier.
“We’re just frustrated that our attempts to constructively engage in order to resolve numerous long-term issues have been met with a lack of engagement on this one,” he said. “We question the government’s dedication to the very people who put them there.”
He said many of the issues his organization previously identified overlap with areas of the laws and regulations being considered for review, yet very little in the modernization process addresses the group’s concerns.
“If it’s being handled this way, what are they trying to get away with? There’s no other way to interpret it,” Heidecker said.
The government website states the engagement reflects the province’s “commitment to ensuring regulatory processes are clear and necessary for proponents seeking to invest and create jobs in Alberta.” The department adds that it “will work directly with other regulators, industry operators, potentially impacted associations (aggregate, oil sands, consulting, forestry, oil and gas, and agricultural), environmental non-government organizations, and municipalities to gather perspectives.”
There is no mention of Indigenous involvement. Knowlton said the government refuses to listen, adding that “our Treaty relationship requires Nation-to-Nation engagement.”
“We are not stakeholders, we are the original stewards of our territories,” he said. “We hold Treaty rights which are protected under the Constitution.”
Sarah Elmeligi, the Alberta NDP shadow minister for Environment and Protected Areas, called the consultation an “insult and a joke,” adding that she has spoken with several stakeholders who were excluded from the process and she does not know who was invited.
“The EPEA is one of the most important and influential pieces of environmental legislation in Alberta,” said Elmeligi in a statement to The Mix.
“Modernizing the act is valuable, (but) giving important and relevant stakeholders less than two weeks to provide detailed comments is a complete disrespect of the dedicated Albertans that work in this field,” she said.
Elmeligi said ignoring environmental experts and Indigenous peoples’ views is causing Albertans to lose trust in the government.













We must all do our part to address the causes of global warming and recognize the recognize the part it plays in causing forest fires.