Cedar, fir, and hemlock trees as old as 800 years have temporary protection after an agreement was reached between four Vancouver Island First Nations and a forestry company.
The deal between four nations in the Nanwakolas Council and Western Forest Products Inc. announced last Wednesday will allow for a two-year deferral of logging for 25 square kilometres of rare, ancient, and priority old-growth trees, The Canadian Press reports.
- The climate news you need. Subscribe now to our engaging new weekly digest.
- You’ll receive exclusive, never-before-seen-content, distilled and delivered to your inbox every weekend.
- The Weekender: Succinct, solutions-focused, and designed with the discerning reader in mind.
In November, the government said it would defer the logging of B.C.’s most rare old-growth trees and gave 200 First Nations a deadline to decide if they supported the deferrals or if they thought further discussion was required.
Nanwakolas Council president Dallas Smith said the nations took the first step because the area holds cultural and environmental importance.
“Cedar is the tree of life in our culture,” he told CP.
The nations want to make sure this tree is preserved for all future generations, he added.
“For animals and birds to call home, to either carve totem poles, build big houses, build canoes, those sorts of things that we’ve sort of taken for granted while we’ve seen the stockpile deplete.”
The Tlowitsis, K’omoks, Wei Wai Kum, and We Wai Kai First Nations have territory that extends south of Comox Valley up through Port McNeil and into the B.C. Mainland. However, Smith said this agreement only concerns central Vancouver Island.
The agreement is important not only to protect the big trees but the habitat around them, since some of the giants left standing alone in a clearcut have later blown down, he said.
The agreement includes preservation of 10 square kilometres of forest identified by a B.C. government old-growth advisory panel as needing protection. Another 15 square kilometres of priority ancient forests were also deferred through agreements between the nations and the forestry firm.
First Nations have worked for years to ensure their cultural values were incorporated into discussions about forests and all that they hold, Smith said, and all of that came together with the agreement.
“Well, it’s a small start with the 2,500 hectares,” he said. “We still have other areas within our territory that are going to come under a similar regime.”
Eagles, hawks, ravens, deer, and elk, among other plants and animals, call those forests home, he said. “Elk habitats very important to us in this discussion. Elk habitats are a big driver for this dialogue.”
Forests Minister Katrine Conroy said Wednesday the temporary logging halt in sections of old-growth is an important measure giving First Nations and the forest industry time and space to develop long-term strategies.
“A temporary deferral is a step in a long-term partnership and vision for forest management that will benefit local communities and ecosystem health,” she told media.
Shannon Janzen, Western’s vice-president of partnership and sustainability, said the agreement shows that forest management can be balanced with environmental, social, and cultural practices.
Smith said another part of the agreement is that any other harvesting will have to be done after approval with all First Nations communities. “We do have some trees that we’ve set aside for totem poles or canoes because they take a tree of a certain magnitude to do so,” he noted.
“We’ve identified a few of those within the area that are acceptable to harvest, but we’re really trying to limit and stop the big tree harvesting from our territory.”
Last summer’s deadly heat dome, floods, and forest fires in the province last year highlighted the importance of trees and intact rainforests, Smith added. The protection ensures that First Nations are helping to mitigate some of the impacts of climate change, while protecting biodiversity.
“So, it’s really important to have this network of protection areas that go up and down the coast so we can make sure we’re doing our part.”
Just want to be clear that this is a deferral, not protection. Myself, I’m not sure I would title this article “Temporary Deal on Old Growth Protections”. People might think you are referring to protection of the 400,000 hectares of Premium old growth left. Temporary is a good word. “Temporary deferral” is more accurate than temporary deal.
FYI, The Province’s track record on converting recommended deferrals to protection runs around 1%. 99% gets cut anyways. 1% gets protected. Those are numbers we’ve observed in other deferral deals.
The Province will cut 700 hectares today, and every day. The City of Nanaimo every two weeks. The Lower Mainland every year. 40% of that will be old growth. This deferral will not slow the actual rate of cut. They are simply handing out more contracts elsewhere. Some of those extra contracts may well be in Fairy Creek, such as Eden Grove.
This 2,500 hectare deferral is therefor a 2,500 hectare death sentence for some other trees that were not currently on the chopping block. The whole process is a shell game. The Allowable Annual Cut is not being reduced, just “traded”, like “carbon credits”.
For perspective, the 2,500 hectares referred to in this temporary deferral represents .0001 of the Provincial forest harvest base.
This agreement does not even admit that clearcutting is unsustainable, or change forestry practices away from clearcutting. A long way to go here, people. Thanks for the article.
If readers want some science on how unsustainable clearcutting is, and what it costs us, please read this:
https://www.vigilancemagazine.com/post/what-is-the-real-story-at-fairy-creek?utm_campaign=d2ba7865-bf93-478e-b40a-22f6279ce9ec&utm_source=so&utm_medium=mail&cid=e8664101-ff86-4681-90ca-fb51741ce6a9
How much did the logging company pay or the right to harvest the old-growth forest? There is a major disconnect here between what industry pays to harvest timber for a PROFIT, and the damage to eco-systems and to the climate caused by their activities, the costs of which we all are forced to bear.