The Great Lakes are getting warmer, wetter, and wilder, three Windsor-area researchers write for The Conversation. And those “typical conditions” are amplifying other threats to the region.
Harmful algal blooms are increasing in severity and geographic extent, sewers are overflowing, and stormwater is flooding neighbourhoods and parks, write the University of Windsor’s John Hartig, Patrícia Galvão Ferreira, and Robert Michael McKay. Many terrestrial organisms are shifting northwards, and worsening air quality is disproportionately affecting the most vulnerable people living in cities.
The Great Lakes hold one-fifth the standing freshwater on the Earth’s surface and more than 34 million people live in the basin, supporting an economy worth US$5 trillion—if it were a country, it would be one of the largest economies in the world. And yet shoreline communities are faltering under the weight of billions of dollars in damages—and are worried that climate change will continue to make things even worse.
Like the Arctic’s thawing permafrost, the Great Lakes basin is a key sentinel of climate change. Climate change has already immensely affected the region and its impacts will continue to expand as the pace of climate change accelerates, bringing new socio-economic and environmental challenges.
With the UN climate conference in Glasgow, COP 26, under way, world leaders are discussing what must be done to address the climate crisis and making pledges to take specific actions. Adaptation features heavily in the COP 26 agenda, including the Glasgow Adaptation Imperative to assess action taken and action needed to meet the Paris Agreement goal on adaptation and promote a more climate-resilient future for all, particularly the most vulnerable communities and ecosystems.
Lake Superior Above All
All the Great Lakes are warming, but Lake Superior stands out. Still the coldest lake, its summer surface water temperatures increased 2.5°C between 1979 and 2006, even faster than air temperatures. Even the deep waters of Lake Michigan are warming at a rate of 0.5°C per decade.
The Great Lakes have lost more than 70% of their total winter ice cover over the past 50 years. That means more open water during winter, thinner ice, and less of the ice fishing that is so popular with basin denizens. Less ice cover will, however, lengthen the commercial shipping season.
Overall, warming of the lakes will alter the seasonal patterns of warm and cold water layers and the dynamics of the lakes’ food webs, and it will lead to greater shoreline damage from strong winter storms.
In some areas within the Great Lakes basin, water levels have risen by two metres, eroding shorelines, washing away houses, destroying roads, threatening infrastructure such as water treatment plants, and disrupting age-old traditions of Indigenous peoples.
Climate change is one of the leading threats to birds in the Great Lakes and North America. A 2019 Audubon report found that 64% of bird species (389 of 604) across breeding and non-breeding seasons were moderately or highly vulnerable to climate change. As indicator species, birds are telling us the time to act is now.
In addition, climate change will likely alter the range and distribution of certain fish species, increase the frequency and severity of harmful algal blooms, exacerbate wetland loss, create new threats from invasive species, diminish beach health and, in some cases, displace or extirpate native species.
Urban Impacts of Climate Change
The effects of climate change are heightened in urban areas and impose a high financial burden on municipalities. Detroit is a good example.
Detroit is an old city with combined storm and sanitary sewers that overflow stormwater and raw sewage during heavy rainfall events. It also has plenty of impervious surfaces that promote runoff.
Extreme rainfall events have flooded highways, streets, and neighbourhoods. High water levels have frequently flooded Detroit’s Jefferson-Chalmers neighbourhood. In response, the city spent $2 million in 2020 on “tiger dams,” large, temporary, water-filled berms, to keep the water from flooding houses.
On the 398-hectare Belle Isle State Park, high water levels closed roads, flooded picnic areas, and postponed 60 weddings at the popular Boat House, a more than 100-year-old rowing facility, in 2019. They have also delayed a $5-million habitat restoration project on Blue Heron Lagoon and forced the redesign of the one-hectare, $4.2-million Oudolf Garden, designed by Piet Oudolf, an internationally renowned Dutch garden designer.
Detroit is also projected to experience a significant increase in the number of very hot days by the end of the century, reaching as many as 65 days above 32.2°C. The burden of heat and poor air quality accompanying the climate threat will disproportionately affect the city’s most vulnerable residents.
Adapting to Climate Change
Many municipalities, provinces, and states around the Great Lakes have been developing adaptation plans to address local impacts of climate change at a high cost. This decentralized approach comes with its own problems, like unintended cross-border effects of local adaptation or duplication of efforts. The United Nations has shown that flood risk reduction strategies in one part of a basin may increase flood risks in another portion of the basin that is located in another country.
An integrated, basin-wide ecosystem approach could allow for cost-sharing of scientific studies and coordinated policy action at national and sub-national levels, leading to better adaptation. Because the Great Lakes are a shared resource among many governments, including those of Canada, the United States, eight states, two provinces and tribes, First Nations, and the Métis Nation, transboundary cooperation is needed.
In 2017, the Great Lakes Water Quality Board of the International Joint Commission, an independent advisor to Canada and the United States, recommended that both countries negotiate and develop a coordinated strategy for climate change adaptation and ecological resilience. These recommendations reflect strong public opinion, yet almost five years later no comprehensive binational climate change strategy has been put into place.
The Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement calls for strengthened measures to anticipate and prevent ecological harm by following the precautionary principle—when human activities may lead to unacceptable harm that is scientifically plausible but uncertain, actions shall be taken to avoid or diminish that harm.
There is enough scientific evidence that climate change poses a threat to the entire Great Lakes region—and the 38 million people who live there. As is being discussed and pledged at COP 26, all must work together to limit global warming to 1.5°C, including the Great Lakes region, and all must immediately advance climate adaptation and resilience.
This story was republished by The Canadian Press.