• About
    • Which Energy Mix is this?
  • Climate News Network Archive
  • Contact
Celebrating our 1,000th edition. The climate news you need
No Result
View All Result
The Energy Mix
  • Canada
  • UK & Europe
  • Fossil Fuels
  • Ending Emissions
  • Community Climate Finance
  • Clean Electricity Grid
  • Cities & Communities
SUBSCRIBE
DONATE
  • Canada
  • UK & Europe
  • Fossil Fuels
  • Ending Emissions
  • Community Climate Finance
  • Clean Electricity Grid
  • Cities & Communities
SUBSCRIBE
DONATE
No Result
View All Result
The Energy Mix
No Result
View All Result
  FEATURED
Ex-Fossil Workers Convert Old Oilfields to Solar Farms After ‘Rapid Upskilling’ in Alberta June 29, 2022
London Becomes Biggest City to Sign Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty June 29, 2022
G7 Miss ‘Golden Opportunity’, Walk Back Pledge to Cut International Fossil Finance June 29, 2022
Soaring Fertilizer Prices Could Deliver ‘Silver Lining’ For Emissions, But Farmers Struggle to Limit Use June 26, 2022
BREAKING: UN Nature Summit, the ‘Paris Conference for Biodiversity’, Moves to Montreal in December June 19, 2022
Next
Prev
Home Jurisdictions Arctic & Antarctica

Supreme Court Affirms Duty to Consult in Rulings that Stop Clyde River Seismic Tests, Endorse Line 9

July 26, 2017
Reading time: 3 minutes

Slp1/GoodFreePhotos

Slp1/GoodFreePhotos

 

In two unanimous rulings yesterday, the Supreme Court of Canada pointed to serious flaws in the National Energy Board’s consultations with Clyde River Inuit over seismic testing in their territory, but determined the Chippewas of the Thames First Nation had adequate opportunity to comment on Enbridge’s proposed Line 9 pipeline reversal in Ontario.

The court “ruled the NEB’s consultation process in Clyde River was ‘significantly flawed’ and gave little, if any, consideration to the treaty rights of Inuit and their reliance on marine mammals for subsistence,” CBC News reports. The Board held only one meeting in the community, did not explain the significance of the “consultation” process, and eventually delivered answers to the mostly Inuktitut-speaking community’s questions by e-transmitting a 3,926-page document, written in English.

“To put it mildly, furnishing answers to questions that went to the heart of the treaty rights at stake in the form of a practically inaccessible document dump months after the questions were initially asked in person is not true consultation,” the court said, in a ruling written by justices Andromache Karakatsanis and Russell Brown.

In the Line 9 case, the court determined that “consultations are a two-way street,” CBC notes, “and Indigenous peoples alone should not be given the final say on whether a project should proceed. Aboriginal rights must be balanced against ‘competing societal interests.’”

Even as it sided with Enbridge in the specific case, the court delivered what CBC called “a shot across the bow”, warning that “any decision affecting Aboriginal or treaty rights made on the basis of inadequate consultation will not be in compliance with the duty to consult.”

“This does not mean that the interests of Indigenous groups cannot be balanced with other interests at the accommodation stage,” Karakatsanis and Brown wrote. “Indeed, it is for this reason that the duty to consult does not provide Indigenous groups with a ‘veto’ over final Crown decisions.”

The court “said the NEB is fully equipped to conduct consultations, and should hold oral hearings and use its broad powers to elicit critical information from proponents such as scientific evidence,” CBC notes. “The NEB should also make money available for Indigenous groups to participate in the process, conduct environmental assessments, and make those findings public.”

Reactions from the two communities were as diametrically opposed as the front-line impacts in the two cases.

“What a victory for us,” said former Clyde River mayor Jerry Natanine, a leading force behind the seismic testing challenge. “We’re not totally against development, but it has to be done right. You know, whales don’t have to die, seals don’t have to die off, plankton. There’s a better way to do these things, that’s what we’ve got to find out.”

But Indigenous rights lawyer Nader Hasan, who represented the small Nunavut community, warned that “the NEB process is broken, the NEB never met a pipeline project or an oil project it didn’t like, and that’s reflected in decades of jurisprudence. Clyde River was successful, but what about the next Clyde River? That community might not have the ability to take their case to the courts.”

Describing the Clyde River ruling as a “wake-up call” for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his cabinet, Hasan called on the federal government fully implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, which requires free, prior and informed consent on projects affecting Indigenous territory.

The Chippewas of the Thames vowed to continue their fight against Line 9, with Chief Myeengun Henry issuing a direct appeal to Enbridge. “I’m going to ask that you, within 30 days, cease operations of tar sands oil through our traditional territory,” he said. “We ask very calmly, we ask non-violently that you consider that, please.”

“I don’t think it was what anyone was expecting, but I definitely think it’s motivation to keep fighting and keep teaching our children to learn our ways and fight in a good way,” said community member Nicole Fourstar.



in Arctic & Antarctica, Canada, Legal & Regulatory, Oil & Gas, Pipelines / Rail Transport

The latest climate news and analysis, direct to your inbox

Subscribe

Related Posts

Keith Hirsche
Jobs & Training

Ex-Fossil Workers Convert Old Oilfields to Solar Farms After ‘Rapid Upskilling’ in Alberta

June 29, 2022
392
London Eye UK England
Cities & Communities

London Becomes Biggest City to Sign Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty

June 29, 2022
120
Number 10/flickr
International Agencies & Studies

G7 Miss ‘Golden Opportunity’, Walk Back Pledge to Cut International Fossil Finance

June 29, 2022
142

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Trending Stories

Keith Hirsche

Ex-Fossil Workers Convert Old Oilfields to Solar Farms After ‘Rapid Upskilling’ in Alberta

June 29, 2022
392
François GOGLINS/wikimedia commons

Corrosion Problem Shutters Half of France’s Nuclear Reactors

June 29, 2022
223
David/flickr

U.S. Supreme Court Expected to Gut Emission Controls as Climate Scientists Petition for Plan B

June 26, 2022
1.2k
Danielle Scott/flickr

Advocate Urges Ottawa to Intervene Before Ontario Builds Highway 413

June 29, 2022
128
Number 10/flickr

G7 Miss ‘Golden Opportunity’, Walk Back Pledge to Cut International Fossil Finance

June 29, 2022
142
London Eye UK England

London Becomes Biggest City to Sign Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty

June 29, 2022
120

Recent Posts

AJEL / Pixabay

Windfall Tax on Food, Fossil, Pharma Giants Would Raise $490B to Solve ‘Catastrophic’ Food Crisis: Oxfam

June 29, 2022
57
futureatlas.com/flickr

Ottawa Demands Deeper Fuel Emissions Cuts, Offers Fossils a Double-Dip on Tax Breaks

June 29, 2022
77
Province of B.C./flickr

Comox Joins Municipalities Seeking Ban on New Gas Stations

June 29, 2022
75
/Piqsels

Refocus Agriculture Spending to Cut Emissions, Boost Productivity, OECD Urges Governments

June 29, 2022
28
Jimmy Emerson, DVM/flickr

Public Vigilance Key to Protecting Greenbelts for Climate Resilience, Report Finds

June 29, 2022
35
Miguel V/Wikimedia Commons

Forests Fall Short of Full Carbon Storage Potential, Study Finds

June 29, 2022
62
Next Post
http://beaconenergynews.ca/energy-news/bc-first-nation-rejects-1-15b-pacific-northwest-lng-deal/

‘Market Awash in LNG’ Spells End of $36-Billion Petronas Project in B.C.

The Energy Mix

Copyright 2022 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy and Copyright
  • Cookie Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Canada
  • UK & Europe
  • Fossil Fuels
  • Ending Emissions
  • Community Climate Finance
  • Clean Electricity Grid
  • Cities & Communities

Copyright 2022 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}