Canada’s biggest oil companies are cashing in on Donald Trump’s war on Iran, with the four biggest oil sands producers reporting a staggering $13.3 billion in profits in the three months ending June 30. And economist Jim Stanford says Canadian households and businesses are paying the price.
And while the binge of high oil prices and company revenues isn’t translating into a longer-term commitment to expanded oil production, things could be headed in that direction, Stanford told The Energy Mix this week.
“There’s nothing like a good war to fill the coffers of the oil industry,” writes Stanford, director of the Centre for Future Work, in an opinion piece for the Toronto Star. And incredibly, there’ve been 14 global oil price shocks since 1973, according to analysis by BNEF founder Michael Liebreich—most of them caused by war or other geopolitical tensions, and all with the same result.
“Whenever the dogs of war are unleashed, the oil industry rakes it in—at least until peace is restored,” Stanford writes,” since oil is a “uniquely concentrated commodity”. It’s only found in certain regions of the world, and it’s “in the hands of some of the biggest corporations on the planet.”
Those realities have driven world oil prices up 50% since the U.S. and Israel launched their war on Iran in late February, he says. Canadians are paying the price because “we’ve tied our own oil prices to the same global roller coaster. It doesn’t cost any more to produce, refine, and distribute petroleum products here than before the war started,” but the four biggest publicly-traded producers—Cenovus Energy, Suncor Energy, Imperial Oil, and Canadian Natural Resources Ltd.—are still aligning with the global market.
The result is that their combined profits this year could hit $100 billion. “That’s great for shareholders. But the money has to come from somewhere. It comes from consumers”—even consumers in Alberta, “who pay inflated prices for gasoline just like the rest of us.”
Whetting Shareholders’ Appetite for More
With their newfound wealth pouring into shareholder dividends and share buybacks, the four big oil sands producers aren’t showing any immediate commitment to new extraction facilities, Stanford told The Mix. For that to happen, the companies “would have to have a sea change in their expectations about the future of their industry,” he explained. “Right now, and for some years, they have implicitly accepted the idea that oil demand is going to peak and fall over time. There are all kinds of reasons for that, climate policy just being one of many.”
So their strategy as a “mature” industry is to “milk it for all it’s worth and make money while the sun is shining, without expecting that this will be an industry that carries on for decades into the future.”
But it isn’t impossible that the “super profits” the companies are seeing now will whet investors’ appetites for more—just as they did during the last oil price shock, after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022.
“One of the more damaging consequences of these profits is how it shifts the incentives for capital to move into an industry that still doesn’t have a long-term future, and it makes renewable energies—which can be profitable, but not this profitable—look like a poor cousin,” Stanford said. “So it’s leading to some misallocation decisions. And it’s certainly possible that if they had certainty that [Canada’s] climate rules were gone, that the regulations on pipeline development were gone, if they had certainty that they didn’t have to invest in silly carbon capture projects, that they could just get straight to the business of extracting and profiting, then we could certainly see more oil sands plants being built.”
But even if the companies never plan to invest a dime in new production capacity, we won’t hear them say it out loud anytime soon.
“The oil industry has a challenge to legitimate what it’s doing, to legitimate how much money it’s making, courtesy in part of the high prices that Canadian consumers pay, and of course trying to legitimate its climate consequences,” Stanford told The Mix. “Even if they have no intention of investing more in new projects, they’ll still stand up and point a finger at government, trying to deflect blame for the inequality and [economic] stagnation that result from their own actions…. and too many people swallow that argument.”
No One Seems Keen to Invest
So far, there’s little sign that oil or pipeline companies or their investors are clamouring to get new projects up and running. After the government of Prime Minister Mark Carney scoured the planet for private investors for its coveted and controversial West Coast Pipeline, it ended up with taxpayers covering 90% of the $35- to $47-billion cost, after previously vowing that approval of the project would be contingent on a private sector proponent.
Days later, Energy and Natural Resources Minister Tim Hodgson told CBC Power & Politics the pipeline would be a “good investment” for taxpayers.
Related: Tell us your better ideas for investing $43.7 billion of your tax dollars!
Then in late July, Calgary-based pipeliner Enbridge Inc. announced it was postponing a 250,000-barrel-per-day second phase of its Mainline crude oil pipeline network, partly because Canadian oil producers had not committed to significant increases in output, Reuters reported. Just as Stanford said, CEO Greg Ebel and Colin Gruending, the company’s president of liquids pipelines, maintained that Enbridge won’t invest until the massive, recent changes in federal regulatory policy are enshrined in law.
Another cautionary note came from TD Economics in late July, in an analysis that summarized recent developments on the West Coast Pipeline and the Pathways carbon capture project. While some news reports highlighted TD’s projection of a “meaningful” economic boost from the pipeline, economists Marc Ercolao and Likeleli Seitlheko warned that that outcome isn’t a sure thing.
‘A Bit of Caution’ as Chinese Imports Decline
While the million-barrel-per-day pipeline would be “transformative” in scale, they wrote, its economic rationale “rests largely on market access and price realization rather than new incremental production alone,” at a time when growth in Asian oil demand is slowing.
“Asian demand would likely dominate much of the new pipeline’s throughput in the 2030s,” the two economists added. But with no expectation that the new pipeline would begin operations before 2032 or 2034, “a bit of caution is warranted. Asia’s oil use is expected to flatten over time as Chinese demand approaches a peak over the next decade, driven by rapid electric vehicle adoption and a gradual shift toward cleaner energy. Further, Canadian heavy barrels will continue to face competition from discounted alternatives such as Russian crude.”
The analysis didn’t factor in the International Energy Agency’s projection that Chinese oil demand will peak in 2027, two years earlier than previously forecast. The IEA attributed that largely to “extraordinary” domestic sales of EVs, high-speed rail, and gas-fuelled trucks that will “help displace crude oil,” Bloomberg News wrote.
Already, the U.S. Energy Information Agency is reporting a sharp drop in China’s oil imports between April and June this year, while identifying eight primary suppliers that are seeing their Chinese sales begin to falter. Heatmap says demand for refined petroleum products is down 13% globally and 4% in the U.S. “While in the short run this is likely due to higher prices, it is consistent with falling forecasts for oil demand.”
“TD says even the best case scenario for an oil pipeline is quite financially risky,” veteran government affairs consultant Aaron Freeman wrote on LinkedIn. “If industry wants to take this risk, that’s their bet, but any public subsidies are a terrible deal for taxpayers.”
“There will always be people who argue that renewables got subsidies—but they have not received nearly the amount of fossil fuels,” agreed Allison Hawkins, vice president of corporate affairs at AMIDA 3D. “Renewables don’t pollute, they don’t leave behind tail ponds that are a liability indefinitely, and they don’t abandon wells that emit pollution. Mass pollution is not a necessary outcome of energy—we choose this outcome.” And with the rest of the world “moving fast toward alternative energy sources,” she added, “the markets for fossil fuels will continue to shrink.”
No Spending Surge Despite Windfall Profits
On global markets, even a potential windfall of US$495 billion this year won’t be enough for a “cash rich but capital conscious” oil industry to open a new “spending surge,” analysts at Wood Mackenzie told industry newsletter Rigzone in late July.
At the beginning of the year, companies expected Brent crude, the price benchmark for European oil blends, to “average around $60 per barrel,” WoodMac said in a statement. But even with prices averaging $91 per barrel through the first half of the year, “capital budgets have barely moved. Companies have broadly maintained their original shareholder return frameworks.”
Budgets for new oil development are “on course for a second consecutive year of slight decline,” even though 155 of the companies in the survey will see their production fall 30% between 2030 and 2040, and 70 will face declines of 50% or more.
“High prices ease the financial pressure,” said Tom Ellacott, the firm’s senior VP of corporate research. “They do not solve the next-decade production challenge.”
Meanwhile, with midterm elections just 84 days away, according to our handy countdown app, Heatmap says high profits for fossil majors like ExxonMobil and Chevron are already “stoking outrage” in the U.S.
“The mugging at Mar-a-Lago just keeps getting worse,” former Washington State governor Jay Inslee (D) said in a statement. “The president said he would sell out Americans to oil and gas CEOs for a billion dollars in campaign donations. Now we know he owns millions of dollars’ worth of their stock. Those same companies are profiting from Trump’s war of choice, which has killed and injured U.S. service members, and left consumers struggling to stay afloat.”
“It’s fair to put a windfall profits tax on inordinate windfall profits rather than cut off children’s food programs,” added Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI).
Economist Jim Stanford issued a similar call in Canada.
“Ultimately, we would want to manage domestic oil prices in a different way and probably learn some lessons from the way we manage electricity prices and natural gas distribution charges,” he told The Mix. But over the shorter run, Canada should “claim back some of those war profits in the form of an excess profit tax, similar to what we did with the banks during COVID.” The funds could either be used to rebate the extra costs Canadians are paying for fossil energy, he said, or to fund heat pumps and energy efficiency measures to help households cut their energy bills permanently.










